Explore Homes for Sale in Monticello, IN
Map Search for Monticello, IN Homes for Sale

Discover Monticello, IN: Your Premier Guide to Homes for Sale with Kimberly Sut Group

  Advanced Search   Market Reports   Home Value   Connect

Embark on your journey to find exceptional Monticello, IN homes for sale with Kimberly Sut Group. As a vibrant community nestled between the picturesque Lake Shafer and Lake Freeman, Monticello offers diverse real estate opportunities. From charming lakeside cottages perfect for weekend escapes to spacious family residences in established neighborhoods, our expert team provides unparalleled insight into the local market. Explore properties that cater to various lifestyles, whether you're seeking recreational access, top-rated schools, or a tranquil small-town atmosphere. Let Kimberly Sut Group be your trusted partner in navigating the unique Monticello real estate landscape.

Search Monticello, IN by Lifestyle
Search Monticello, IN by Price
Search Monticello, IN by Bedrooms
Search Monticello, IN by Bathrooms

Exploring Monticello, IN Homes for Sale by Lifestyle

Lakeside Living: Lake Shafer & Lake Freeman Properties

The allure of Monticello often begins with its twin lakes. Homes for sale surrounding Lake Shafer and Lake Freeman offer an enviable lifestyle focused on boating, fishing, and watersports. Imagine waking up to serene lake views or spending evenings on your private dock. Properties here range from quaint, seasonal cottages to luxurious year-round estates, many featuring private access, boat lifts, and expansive decks. Finding lakefront homes for sale in Monticello, IN provides direct access to the region's most popular recreational activities.

Family-Friendly Homes Near Top Schools

For families considering Monticello, the availability of quality homes for sale within proximity to reputable schools, particularly within the Twin Lakes School Corporation district, is a significant draw. Many residential areas offer spacious single-family homes with ample yards, ideal for children and pets. Look for homes near neighborhoods like the area surrounding Oaklawn Park or properties with easy commutes to Meadowlawn Elementary or Twin Lakes High School, ensuring convenience for school-aged children.

Downtown Monticello: Historic Charm & Modern Convenience

Transitioning from lakeside properties, the heart of Monticello offers a different but equally appealing selection of homes for sale. Downtown Monticello features a mix of historic homes, some beautifully preserved or updated, offering unique architectural character. Living downtown provides walkable access to local businesses, unique shops, and dining establishments. These homes often appeal to those seeking community engagement and a vibrant town center experience, blending historical charm with modern living amenities.

Diverse Monticello Real Estate: Types of Homes for Sale

Single-Family Homes & Residential Neighborhoods

Beyond the specialized lakefront or historic properties, the majority of Monticello homes for sale fall within the single-family residential category. These range from affordable starter homes in quiet subdivisions like those found towards the Buffalo region, to larger, newly constructed residences. These homes are ideal for first-time buyers, growing families, or those seeking more space and privacy. Kimberly Sut Group can assist in identifying the perfect fit within various price points and neighborhood styles.

Condos, Townhomes, & Low-Maintenance Options

For individuals or couples seeking a lower-maintenance lifestyle, Monticello also offers a selection of condominiums and townhomes for sale. These properties provide an excellent alternative to traditional single-family homes, often including amenities and reducing exterior upkeep responsibilities. Such options are particularly appealing to retirees, empty nesters, or busy professionals desiring convenience without sacrificing community access.

Investment Opportunities & Vacant Land for Sale

Monticello's growing appeal extends to investment properties, including multi-family units and vacation rentals, especially near the lakes. Furthermore, for those dreaming of custom-built residences, numerous parcels of vacant land for sale are available. Whether you envision a new construction near the Tippecanoe River or a secluded lot for a future dream home, the opportunities for building equity in this vibrant market are abundant.

The Monticello Lifestyle: Beyond Homes for Sale

Recreation, Parks & Local Attractions

Life in Monticello extends far beyond its homes for sale; it's a lifestyle rich in recreation and community. Residents enjoy access to numerous parks, including Bluewater Beach and Indiana Beach Amusement Park, offering family fun throughout the warmer months. The city's extensive trail system provides opportunities for walking, jogging, and biking, connecting various parts of the community. Local events, farmers' markets, and cultural activities foster a strong sense of belonging among residents.

Dining, Shopping & Community Services

Monticello boasts a friendly small-town atmosphere complemented by convenient amenities. Local restaurants, from casual diners to more upscale options, cater to diverse tastes. Boutique shops and essential services are readily available, ensuring residents have everything they need close to home. The sense of community is further strengthened by local organizations, volunteer opportunities, and community-focused services, making Monticello an inviting place to live and thrive.

Newest Homes for Sale in Monticello, IN

$99,000
202615359 MLS ⋅ Matt Zook
Looking to build? Here ya go....4 buildable lots, 5 lots in total. Parking space above the lower level lots and off road parking below the upper lots. There was a small fishing shack located on one of the upper lots, it has been removed. The well, TLRSD and electric are all available on the upper lot. There is a public easement that runs through the lower lots leading to a public boat dock, the boat lift 2nd on the right comes with this property.

10971 N Lower Lakeshore Dr, Monticello

Listing courtesy of Matt Zook from REAL ESTATE NETWORK L.L.C. cell: 574-229-0938
$322,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 202613500 MLS ⋅ 2,600 SqFt. ⋅ Michelle Gerhart
Beautifully updated home on the south side of Monticello, located within city limits and offering the perfect blend of comfort and privacy. This spacious 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath home features approximately 2,600 square feet of living space, including a partially finished walk-out basement complete with a pool table and couch—perfect for entertaining. Recent updates include all new appliances, LVP waterproof wood flooring and both stylish bathroom vanities in 2024. The water heater and new sewer line were installed in 2026. Let's not forget about all the other updates between, countertops, backsplash, hardware, hinges/handles, light fixtures, and the new and gorgeous board and bat dining wall. The entire home has been freshly painted inside, with the exterior also updated this spring, giving it a clean, move-in-ready feel. Enjoy a beautifully landscaped yard that feels like your own private oasis, along with a two-car attached garage and a shed for extra storage. LINK TO VIRTUAL TOUR: https://my.matterport.com/show/?m=vM47N3toA2W

110 Brittany Ln, Monticello

Listing courtesy of Michelle Gerhart from VOGEL REAL ESTATE. mgerhart@vogel-real-estate.com
$64,900
202615798 MLS ⋅ Michael Lewis
Lakeview Bay–Interior Lots with Water Access on Lake Shafer. Live the lake life without the lakefront price at Lakeview Bay, a peaceful new subdivision in Monticello offering spacious interior lots with shared access to Lake Shafer via a private community dock. Build your dream home in an exciting new neighborhood designed for both full-time living and weekend escapes. Interior Lot Features: • Shared lakeside common area & courtesy dock exclusively for homeowner use • Variety of interior lot sizes with full utility access: sewer, water, gas, and electric • Minutes from downtown Monticello, Indiana Beach, Tippecanoe Country Club, & across the road from Pineview Golf Course • Protective covenants designed to promote long-term value growth & neighborhood appeal. Enjoy the best of lake living with the convenience & value of an interior lot. Whether you are building a year-round residence or planning for seasonal use, Lakeview Bay offers an ideal setting in an area with limited comparable options. Contact us now for lot availability, pricing, and building guidelines. Don’t miss your chance to become part of this exceptional new development.

2049 Deepwater, Monticello

Listing courtesy of Michael Lewis from REAL ESTATE NETWORK L.L.C. Cell: 574-581-9962
$124,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 202626528 MLS ⋅ 952 SqFt. ⋅ Brenda Sprunger
Discover relaxed lake living in this inviting 2-bedroom, 2-bath home on Lake Freeman! Featuring an open floor plan designed for comfortable living and easy entertaining, this home offers a bright, spacious feel throughout. Step outside to enjoy the large deck — perfect for morning coffee, summer cookouts, or unwinding after a day on the water. A storage shed provides extra space for lake toys, tools, and outdoor equipment. Situated on canal water frontage just minutes from the main waters of Lake Freeman, you’ll enjoy quick and convenient access to boating, fishing, and endless recreation. Residents also enjoy fantastic community amenities including a clubhouse and inground swimming pool, adding even more opportunities for fun and relaxation. Whether you’re searching for a full-time residence, weekend retreat, or investment opportunity, this property offers the ideal combination of comfort, convenience, and lake lifestyle living.

11102 N Landings Rd, Monticello

Listing courtesy of Brenda Sprunger from Redlow Group.

$125,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 202617269 MLS ⋅ 2,232 SqFt. ⋅ Stephanie McKinley
Priced below appraised value! Step inside this home with tons of potential and vintage charm. You are welcomed with original hardwood floors (plus some flooring that has been updated!), 4 large bedrooms, 2 full baths, and a fully fenced in side yard. The tall ceilings make the home feel so much larger than it already is! So many possibilities with 214 W. Washington St. You’ll enjoy the front sunroom (perfect for relaxation or plants!), the large detached garage, and being close to downtown. The original wood work around the doors, windows, and the staircase are unmatched.

214 W Washington St, Monticello

Listing courtesy of Stephanie McKinley from Raeco Realty.

$699,000
5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 202606031 MLS ⋅ 4,724 SqFt. ⋅ Joan Abbott
**Lake Shafer Retreat – Stunning Waterfront Property!!** This beautifully designed home offers prime access to Main Lake Shafer, making it ideal for relaxing weekends on the water or sitting by the 15 x 38 heated pool. This home features 5/6 spacious bedrooms which provides plenty of room for guests or family members. 3 full baths with the primary being on main level with tiled walk in shower, soaking/jacuzzi tub and oversized walk in closet. The Open-concept kitchen flows into the living space with beautiful built-in cabinetry creating an inviting atmosphere. You will love the two gas fireplaces, original hardwood floors, newly renovated bath off the kitchen, updated flooring and NEW appliances, NEW roof, furnace and AC in 2024. The Large concrete patio offers breathtaking views and outdoor entertaining, Stunning white vinyl privacy fence and steps leading to 125 ft. of water frontage, steel seawall and 2 electric covered boat lifts. Conveniently located near local shopping, dining, and town amenities. Whether you're looking for a vacation retreat, year-round home, or maybe a summer time Airbnb? this property checks all the boxes!

5259 E Willow Ct, Monticello

Listing courtesy of Joan Abbott from Joan Abbott Real Estate. Agt: 765-564-9822
$319,900
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 202617389 MLS ⋅ 921 SqFt. ⋅ Sean Dekker
AFFORDABLE & ADORABLE! Step into this 'breath of fresh air' lake cottage & you'll immediately feel that Lake Life Vibe with this 3 bedroom delight and its open concept & freshly updated interior. The span of lake-view windows add to the cheerful surroundings, as well as immediate access to the attractive composite deck outside, overlooking Lake Shafer and the lot's lake level waterfront, pier/dock & boatlift. Plenty of parking & yard space for activities, but BONUS!: just across the street is the neighborhood's private playground & inground swimming pool! The "bow" on this perfect vacation package is that it comes nicely furnished! The price includes an all new heat & AC unit just installed. We priced this one nicely for all of the priceless Summer memories you'll be creating!

6855 N Skaggs Ct, Monticello

Listing courtesy of Sean Dekker from REAL ESTATE NETWORK L.L.C.

$460,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 202627929 MLS ⋅ 1,880 SqFt. ⋅ Kim Reid
Experience the ease of brand-new, one-level living in this thoughtfully designed 3-bedroom, 2-bath brick ranch home. The open concept floor plan offers comfortable living and entertaining, while quality finishes and modern conveniences make this home truly move-in ready. The spacious primary suite features a full bathroom and walk-in closet, and two additional bedrooms provide flexibility for family, guests, or a home office. A concrete walkway extends from the front entrance to the rear patio, creating convenient access and an inviting outdoor space to relax or entertain. Don't miss this opportunity to make this beautiful newly built home your own!

814 W Washington St, Monticello

Listing courtesy of Kim Reid from Envision Real Estate Team - Logansport. Cell: 574-721-4544
$399,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 202626076 MLS ⋅ 2,160 SqFt. ⋅ Jace Hicks
OPEN HOUSE AUG 30 1-3 p.m. The actual address GPS coordinates are as follows 40.76183697529391 -86.75329010497451 Type in 200 E. STATE ROAD 16 Monticello IN 47960 This beautiful fully remodeled 4-bedroom, 2-bath home offers the perfect blend of comfort, space, and lake living on scenic Lake Shafer. Designed for both everyday living and entertaining, this inviting property features spacious living areas, generously sized bedrooms, and thoughtful updates throughout. The finished basement creates an exceptional gathering space ideal for hosting, game days, or relaxing evenings at home. An oversized garage provides abundant room for vehicles, lake toys, tools, and storage, offering the flexibility today's homeowners desire. Enjoy the convenience of being just moments from boating, fishing, dining, and all the recreational opportunities that make the Lake Shafer area one of Monticello's most sought-after destinations. Whether you're looking for a year-round residence, a weekend retreat, or a place to create lasting memories, this exceptional property delivers the lifestyle you've been searching for.

200 E State Road 16th Hwy, Monticello

Listing courtesy of Jace Hicks from Summerland Realty Group, LLC.

$325,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 202611812 MLS ⋅ 1,620 SqFt. ⋅ Chris Thayer
MOTIVATED SELLER! Situated on over half an acre with 120' of waterfront, the big-ticket shorefront improvements are already in place, including a steel seawall, a double permanent boatlift, and a personal chairlift. Additionally, there is a three-car garage, a double carport, and a spacious asphalt drive. This lake home has recently undergone a comprehensive makeover, including three new mini-split units added for air conditioning. There is a new bathroom, new flooring, fresh paint throughout, and more. The before-and-after is a huge difference! The interior of the home offers three bedrooms plus a loft, a living room with a bay window, and a family room with a fireplace. Let the lake be your playground at this property, with lakeside fun, a great home, plenty of space for your waterfront toys, and close proximity to city conveniences!

336 N Beach Dr, Monticello

Listing courtesy of Chris Thayer from REAL ESTATE NETWORK L.L.C. Cell: 574-870-1354
$382,090
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 842836 MLS ⋅ 1,765 SqFt. ⋅ Kimberly Sut
Lake life is calling! 2 Lots included. This well-maintained 3-bedroom, 2-bath home offers the perfect combination of comfortable living, extra storage, and easy access to the water. Situated on one of the largest corner lots in the neighborhood, this property includes two parcels, giving you additional space and your own private lake access just across the street. Inside, you'll find a spacious layout featuring a welcoming kitchen with a center island, soft-close cabinetry, updated countertops, and plenty of room for gathering. The primary suite includes a private en-suite bathroom, creating a comfortable retreat at the end of the day. Step outside through the double patio doors to an area complete with an electric awning, making it easy to relax and entertain in nearly any weather. The partially fenced backyard provides room for pets, play, gardening, or outdoor enjoyment. Storage is no issue with an attached 2-car garage plus two additional detached garages/storage buildings, offering space for extra vehicles, boats, recreational equipment, or a workshop. An RV electrical hookup adds even more versatility for campers, motorhomes, or specialty equipment. Just across the street, your second parcel provides access to the lake where you can spend your days boating, fishing, swimming, or simply unwinding by the water. The electric boat lift is already in place--just bring your boat--and the private pier is perfect for casting a line, enjoying the views, or watching the sunset. A charming gazebo creates the ideal spot to relax and take in the peaceful lake scenery. Whether you're looking for a full-time residence, a weekend getaway, or the ultimate lake retreat, this property offers an incredible opportunity to enjoy everything lake living has to offer. With so many features and amenities, this home is truly one you need to experience in person. Schedule your private showing today!

5008 E Shady Point Drive, Monticello

Listing courtesy of Kimberly Sut from Listing Leaders Executive RE.

$259,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 842039 MLS ⋅ 1,344 SqFt. ⋅ Michael Santos
BEAUTIFUL LAKE SHAFER BRICK RANCH -- (SELLER OFFERING BUYER A 5000 CREDIT INCENTIVE) Picture yourself living here in this sought-after west side Lake Shafer community, this brick ranch leaves nothing to do but unpack. So your weekends can go to the water, not the to-do list. Inside: open-concept living, dining, and kitchen with modern plank flooring running through the main spaces and all three bedrooms. The kitchen features a center island, mosaic tile backsplash, stainless double-bowl sink, and full stainless-steel appliance package (gas range, microwave, dishwasher, refrigerator). A bright all-seasons sunroom with panoramic vinyl windows and an exposed brick accent wall that adds bonus space you'll actually use, while the utility/mudroom entry (washer/dryer hookups, boiler, water heater, and softener) makes the perfect lake-day drop zone. Both baths are fully updated with floor-to-ceiling tile and custom niches, including a walk-in glass corner shower in the primary ensuite. Outside: You get a newer concrete driveway and wrap-around walkways (poured two years ago), manicured landscaping with stone edging, brick pavers, white river-rock beds, and solar path lighting. Enjoy a private back deck built for grilling or morning coffee, a storage shed with double doors and entry ramp, plus a covered front porch. The oversized heated two-car garage offers direct kitchen access, pull-down attic access, built-in storage, and room for a workshop or second fridge. Steps from Lake Shafer and a short walk to the Indiana Beach. Only minutes away you have High-Speed racing at Kaminsky Park or play a round of golf on the Historic Greens at Tippecanoe Country Club designed by renowned architect Pete Dye. And end the night watching your favorite movies at nostalgic Lake Shore Drive-In Theater. All this with an easy 30-mile straight shot to Lafayette. This updated, low-maintenance home in this neighborhood won't last. Book your walkthrough today before it's gone.

2155 N West Shafer Drive, Monticello

Listing courtesy of Michael Santos from Mount Moriah Group.

Start Your Search

Updated . Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker of MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information. Some listings have been excluded from this website.