Homes for Sale in Monticello, IN Between $450,000 to $500,000

Advanced Search Market Reports Home Value Connect

Welcome to your dedicated resource for Homes for Sale Between $450,000 to $500,000 in Monticello, IN. This page is your live portal for listings that match the exact homes for sale you demand, filtering out irrelevant properties to save you time. As a local Monticello, IN agent, Kimberly Sut Group specializes in the unique market dynamics of this area, offering insights into amenities, home values, and investment potential. Start exploring the properties currently available between $450,000 to $500,000 below, or contact a local agent to discuss the details that matters most to your search.

< Back to all Homes for Sale in Monticello, IN

Search Monticello, IN by Price

All Monticello, IN Homes for Sale Between $450,000 to $500,000

$469,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 202636937 MLS ⋅ 1,630 SqFt. ⋅ Cheryl L Rycraft

GET READY TO ENJOY WATERFRONT LIVING ! THIS 3 BEDROOM, 1 1/2 -BATH LAKE HOME OFFERS BEAUTIFUL LAKE VIEWS, 58' OF WATERFRONT, 2 BOAT LIFTS,+2 JET SKI LIFTS, MULTIPLE DECKS, ONE WITH A NEWER GAZEBO, STEEL SEAWALL, RETAINING WALLS , AND AN OUT DOOR FIREPLACE. INTERIOR HAS BEEN COMPLETELY REMODELED WITH A NEWER FURNACE, CENTRAL AIR, FLOORING AND KITCHEN. EXTERIOR OFFERS A 3 CAR DETACHED GARAGE SITTING ON THE BONUS LOT ACROSS THE STREET. THIS HOME IS IMMACULATE AND WELL TAKEN CARE OF. DON'T JUST DREAM ABOUT LAKE LIFE-COME LIVE IT!

3838 E Forest Lodge Loop, Monticello

Listing courtesy of Cheryl L Rycraft from REAL ESTATE NETWORK L.L.C. Cell: 574-870-0502

$489,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 202635782 MLS ⋅ 3,322 SqFt. ⋅ Candee Warren

Welcome to a Wonderful Home. Situated across from the 10th hole of the Tippecanoe Country Club, you can sit on your front porch and gaze at the Golf course or the back porch and enjoy Nature. Inside you will find a Lovely Living Room with A Gas Fireplace, Dream Kitchen with Large Island, Quartz Counters, Coffee Bar and Plenty of Storage. The Primary Suite is your own private retreat. 2 Additional Bedrooms and Full Bath are on the Main Floor. The Basement is Fully Finished and Much of the Furniture will Stay. Rec Room, Game Room and 2 additional Finished Rooms along with a Full Bath. Outside is a Large Shed with additional Storage built on the Back, Large Deck with a Retractable Awning, Generac and Beautiful Trees

4658 E Jennings Loop, Monticello

Listing courtesy of Candee Warren from McColly Willowcreek.

$489,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 844518 MLS ⋅ 3,322 SqFt. ⋅ Candee Warren

Welcome to a Wonderful Home. Situated across from the 10th hole of the Tippecanoe Country Club, you can sit on your front porch and gaze at the Golf course or the back porch and enjoy Nature. Inside you will find a Lovely Living Room with a Gas Fireplace, Dream Kitchen with Large Island, Quartz Counters, Coffee Bar and Plenty of Storage. The Primary Suite is your own private retreat. 2 Additional Bedrooms and Full Bath are on the Main Floor. The Basement is Fully Finished and Much of the Furniture will Stay. Rec Room, Game Room and 2 additional Finished Rooms along with a Full Bath. Outside is a Large Shed with additional Storage built on the Back. Large Deck with a Retractable Awning, Generac and Beautiful Trees.

4658 E Jennings Loop, Monticello

Listing courtesy of Candee Warren from McColly Real Estate.

$450,000

2 Baths ⋅ 202621133 MLS ⋅ Jace Hicks

Own a Piece of Downtown History! An exceptional opportunity awaits at 213 N Main St, Monticello, Indiana—an iconic downtown bar and lounge with a long-standing presence in the heart of the city's vibrant business district. This well-known establishment offers a prime Main Street location with outstanding visibility, steady foot traffic, and a reputation that has made it a local favorite for years. Featuring a spacious bar area, comfortable lounge seating, and a welcoming atmosphere, this property is perfectly suited for continued bar and entertainment operations or a new hospitality concept. The central downtown location places you among thriving businesses, community events, and year-round activity. Whether you're an investor, entrepreneur, or experienced operator, this is a rare chance to acquire a recognizable commercial property with tremendous potential in one of North Central Indiana's most desirable lake communities. Highlights: Prime downtown Main Street location Established bar and lounge venue High visibility and strong local presence Spacious interior with flexible layout Opportunity for owner-operator or investment use Located minutes from Lake Shafer and Lake Freeman Bring your vision and capitalize on this unique opportunity to own one of downtown Monticello's most recognizable gathering places. Contact us today for additional information and a private tour.

213 N Main St, Monticello

Listing courtesy of Jace Hicks from Summerland Realty Group, LLC.

$499,900

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 202631409 MLS ⋅ 1,776 SqFt. ⋅ Paul Bunch

Who needs the lake life & over an acre of land with a newer pole barn? Come have a look at 2232 North Norway Trail in Monticello! This move-in ready home sits directly across from Lake Shafer, & offers 98 feet of lakefront access, & a place to have a boatlift & boat. Well-maintained & tastefully decorated, this 3 bedroom, 2 full bath home includes all appliances & is ready for the next owners. 1776 sq ft of finished living space. Plenty of off-street parking, a 2 yr old roof, & a pole barn that's a generous 32' by 24', 10' high inside, & an 8' high garage door. Ready for all the extra storage you could need. Just minutes from Indiana Beach, & all the Monticello community has to offer. Beautiful mature trees provide a shaded oasis & plenty of space for all your outdoor entertaining needs. Beautiful view of the lake from the spacious 24' by 20' deck where you can enjoy quiet mornings or evenings just soaking in all this property has to offer. New blacktop on driveway, all cast iron plumbing removed & replaced to the grinder, main floor new trim, new boat lift, new power ran from house to lakeside outlets near firepit & to pier. Current owners have a boat & portable lift to sell to prospective buyers if interested.

2232 N Norway Trl, Monticello

Listing courtesy of Paul Bunch from Keller Williams Lafayette. Agt: 765-414-3100

$470,000

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 202612504 MLS ⋅ 1,120 SqFt. ⋅ Cheryl L Rycraft

LAKEFRONT LIVING AT ITS BEST! THIS 3 BED, 1 BATH PROPERTY OFFERS 54' FT. OF WATERFRONT, PERMANENT COVERED BOAT LIFT, JET SKI LIFT, MULTIPLE PIERS AND SPACIOUS DECKS PERFECT FOR ENJOYING THE WATER. INTERIOR FEATURES INCLUDE CUSTOM CABINETS, HARDWOOD FLOORS THROUGHOUT, NEWER AC AND FURNANCE. EXTERIOR HIGHLIGHTS INCLUDE A 2 CAR GARAGE, 36 X 48 POLE BUILDING WITH PLENTY OF STORAGE, A WORK SHOP, GAME ROOM, AND A PARTIALLY FENCED YARD. WHETHER YOU'RE LOOKING FOR A WEEKEND GETAWAY OR A FULL TIME LAKE RETREAT, THIS PROPERTY CHECKS ALL THE BOXES.

5889 N Stahl Rd, Monticello

Listing courtesy of Cheryl L Rycraft from REAL ESTATE NETWORK L.L.C. Cell: 574-870-0502

$489,900

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 202617075 MLS ⋅ 2,301 SqFt. ⋅ Sean Dekker

TRUE BLUE AMAZING LAKE VIEWS! Imagine waking up to incredible lake views & then enjoying them with your morning coffee from your bedroom’s private covered lake deck! This 4 Bed / 2.5, 2300+ sf year-round Lake Shafer home features a Bed/Bath combo w/a private lake-view deck on both the main & lower level, a large, open, living & dining area w/fireplace, a cheerful sunroom off of the kitchen, & guest bath with laundry. Enjoy the expansive sights from any one of the multiple decks along your 100+ feet of shoreline or take to the lake from the permanent boat lift. Located in one of the nicest locales on Lake Shafer, this is truly an amazing site for your lake life!

2951 N Lakeshore Dr, Monticello

Listing courtesy of Sean Dekker from REAL ESTATE NETWORK L.L.C.

$460,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 202627929 MLS ⋅ 1,880 SqFt. ⋅ Kim Reid

Experience the ease of brand-new, one-level living in this thoughtfully designed 3-bedroom, 2-bath brick ranch home. The open concept floor plan offers comfortable living and entertaining, while quality finishes and modern conveniences make this home truly move-in ready. The spacious primary suite features a full bathroom and walk-in closet, and two additional bedrooms provide flexibility for family, guests, or a home office. A concrete walkway extends from the front entrance to the rear patio, creating convenient access and an inviting outdoor space to relax or entertain. Don't miss this opportunity to make this beautiful newly built home your own!

814 W Washington St, Monticello

Listing courtesy of Kim Reid from Envision Real Estate Team - Logansport. Cell: 574-721-4544

Start Your Search

Updated . Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker of MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information. Some listings have been excluded from this website.