Explore Homes for Sale in Monticello, IN
Map Search for Monticello, IN Homes for Sale

Discover Monticello, IN: Your Premier Guide to Homes for Sale with Kimberly Sut Group

  Advanced Search   Market Reports   Home Value   Connect

Embark on your journey to find exceptional Monticello, IN homes for sale with Kimberly Sut Group. As a vibrant community nestled between the picturesque Lake Shafer and Lake Freeman, Monticello offers diverse real estate opportunities. From charming lakeside cottages perfect for weekend escapes to spacious family residences in established neighborhoods, our expert team provides unparalleled insight into the local market. Explore properties that cater to various lifestyles, whether you're seeking recreational access, top-rated schools, or a tranquil small-town atmosphere. Let Kimberly Sut Group be your trusted partner in navigating the unique Monticello real estate landscape.

Search Monticello, IN by Lifestyle
Search Monticello, IN by Price
Search Monticello, IN by Bedrooms
Search Monticello, IN by Bathrooms

Exploring Monticello, IN Homes for Sale by Lifestyle

Lakeside Living: Lake Shafer & Lake Freeman Properties

The allure of Monticello often begins with its twin lakes. Homes for sale surrounding Lake Shafer and Lake Freeman offer an enviable lifestyle focused on boating, fishing, and watersports. Imagine waking up to serene lake views or spending evenings on your private dock. Properties here range from quaint, seasonal cottages to luxurious year-round estates, many featuring private access, boat lifts, and expansive decks. Finding lakefront homes for sale in Monticello, IN provides direct access to the region's most popular recreational activities.

Family-Friendly Homes Near Top Schools

For families considering Monticello, the availability of quality homes for sale within proximity to reputable schools, particularly within the Twin Lakes School Corporation district, is a significant draw. Many residential areas offer spacious single-family homes with ample yards, ideal for children and pets. Look for homes near neighborhoods like the area surrounding Oaklawn Park or properties with easy commutes to Meadowlawn Elementary or Twin Lakes High School, ensuring convenience for school-aged children.

Downtown Monticello: Historic Charm & Modern Convenience

Transitioning from lakeside properties, the heart of Monticello offers a different but equally appealing selection of homes for sale. Downtown Monticello features a mix of historic homes, some beautifully preserved or updated, offering unique architectural character. Living downtown provides walkable access to local businesses, unique shops, and dining establishments. These homes often appeal to those seeking community engagement and a vibrant town center experience, blending historical charm with modern living amenities.

Diverse Monticello Real Estate: Types of Homes for Sale

Single-Family Homes & Residential Neighborhoods

Beyond the specialized lakefront or historic properties, the majority of Monticello homes for sale fall within the single-family residential category. These range from affordable starter homes in quiet subdivisions like those found towards the Buffalo region, to larger, newly constructed residences. These homes are ideal for first-time buyers, growing families, or those seeking more space and privacy. Kimberly Sut Group can assist in identifying the perfect fit within various price points and neighborhood styles.

Condos, Townhomes, & Low-Maintenance Options

For individuals or couples seeking a lower-maintenance lifestyle, Monticello also offers a selection of condominiums and townhomes for sale. These properties provide an excellent alternative to traditional single-family homes, often including amenities and reducing exterior upkeep responsibilities. Such options are particularly appealing to retirees, empty nesters, or busy professionals desiring convenience without sacrificing community access.

Investment Opportunities & Vacant Land for Sale

Monticello's growing appeal extends to investment properties, including multi-family units and vacation rentals, especially near the lakes. Furthermore, for those dreaming of custom-built residences, numerous parcels of vacant land for sale are available. Whether you envision a new construction near the Tippecanoe River or a secluded lot for a future dream home, the opportunities for building equity in this vibrant market are abundant.

The Monticello Lifestyle: Beyond Homes for Sale

Recreation, Parks & Local Attractions

Life in Monticello extends far beyond its homes for sale; it's a lifestyle rich in recreation and community. Residents enjoy access to numerous parks, including Bluewater Beach and Indiana Beach Amusement Park, offering family fun throughout the warmer months. The city's extensive trail system provides opportunities for walking, jogging, and biking, connecting various parts of the community. Local events, farmers' markets, and cultural activities foster a strong sense of belonging among residents.

Dining, Shopping & Community Services

Monticello boasts a friendly small-town atmosphere complemented by convenient amenities. Local restaurants, from casual diners to more upscale options, cater to diverse tastes. Boutique shops and essential services are readily available, ensuring residents have everything they need close to home. The sense of community is further strengthened by local organizations, volunteer opportunities, and community-focused services, making Monticello an inviting place to live and thrive.

Newest Homes for Sale in Monticello, IN

$189,900
1 Baths ⋅ 202633867 MLS ⋅ Michelle Gerhart
Prime downtown Monticello office space FOR SALE. Offering 1,827 sq. ft., seven private offices, a storage room, a spacious reception/meeting area, and large front windows for excellent exposure. This property is ready to go and is located just steps from the White County Courthouse. This space is ideal for a wide range of business uses.

116 Constitution Plz, Monticello

Listing courtesy of Michelle Gerhart from VOGEL REAL ESTATE. mgerhart@vogel-real-estate.com
$39,900
202633847 MLS ⋅ Dustin Robinson
Perfect lot for additional lake storage or party barn/toy garage. You can never have too much additional parking and storage at the lake!

10892 N Lower Lakeshore Dr, Monticello

Listing courtesy of Dustin Robinson from Lafayette Listing Realty LLC.

$289,900
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 843960 MLS ⋅ 2,144 SqFt. ⋅ Lisa Malchow
Motivated Seller!! FHA, VA, & USDA offers are welcome! This charming one-story home features 3 to 4 bedrooms and boasts an open-concept layout that seamlessly connects the kitchen, living room, and dining area and is perfect for entertaining.The primary bedroom suite offers a generous space equipped with a walk-in closet, double vanity, a stand-up shower, and a jetted garden tub. Additionally, a versatile bonus room can serve as an extra living area or an in-law suite, complete with its own bathroom, laundry facilities, and a sliding glass door leading to a backyard deck that overlooks the private yard. Situated on a .44-acre lot, there's ample space for outdoor games and the opportunity to grow a large garden. Enjoy the benefits of a low-maintenance home, featuring a brand-new roof with a transferable warranty and a fresh coat of paint on the exterior. Conveniently located just minutes from all the amenities Monticello has to offer, yet providing a tranquil country atmosphere.

213 S Park Drive, Monticello

Listing courtesy of Lisa Malchow from RE/MAX Select Realty.

$168,000
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 202633548 MLS ⋅ 912 SqFt. ⋅ Jeffrey W Bossung
This small but spacious home offers 2 bedrooms, 1 bath, a covered porch, deck in the back and area with a fire pit. hot tub will stay along with all appliances. 2 1 car garages and a double lot. no showings before 3 pm weekdays. dog in the house. MOTIVATED SELLER

618 East St, Monticello

Listing courtesy of Jeffrey W Bossung from VOGEL REAL ESTATE. jbossung@vogel-real-estate.com
$90,000
202633414 MLS ⋅ Michael Lewis
Lakeview Bay – Interior Lots with Lake Shafer Access. Build your dream home in Lakeview Bay, an attractive lakeside community in Monticello offering spacious interior homesites with shared access to Lake Shafer through a private community common area and courtesy dock reserved exclusively for homeowners. Lot 31 is ideally situated across from the common area, offering convenient access to the private stairs, lakeside deck, and temporary mooring pier exclusively for Lakeview Bay homeowners' use. Enjoy pleasant views toward the lake and the convenience of being just steps from the community's waterfront access amenity. Enjoy the benefits of lake living without the maintenance or cost of a waterfront lot. These homesites feature access to public utilities, including sewer, water, natural gas, and electric, and are protected by neighborhood covenants designed to preserve the community's quality and long-term appeal. Conveniently located just minutes from downtown Monticello, Indiana Beach, shopping, restaurants, and Tippecanoe Country Club, Lakeview Bay is also situated directly across from Pine View Golf Course, providing easy access to many of the area's most popular recreational amenities. Whether you're planning a primary residence or a weekend retreat, these lots offer an outstanding opportunity to build in one of Lake Shafer's newest residential communities.

2086 Deepwater, Monticello

Listing courtesy of Michael Lewis from REAL ESTATE NETWORK L.L.C. Cell: 574-581-9962
$85,000
202633413 MLS ⋅ Michael Lewis
Lakeview Bay – Interior Lots with Lake Shafer Access. Build your dream home in Lakeview Bay, an attractive lakeside community in Monticello offering spacious interior homesites with shared access to Lake Shafer through a private community common area and courtesy dock reserved exclusively for homeowners. Situated on the Northeast side of Lakeview Bay, Lot 6 enjoys a highly desirable location with potential for seasonal views of Lake Shafer from the backyard. Enjoy a peaceful setting with convenient access to the subdivision's private common area stairs, lakeside deck and temporary mooring pier for exclusive use by homeowners. Enjoy the benefits of lake living without the maintenance or cost of a waterfront lot. These homesites feature access to public utilities, including sewer, water, natural gas, and electric, and are protected by neighborhood covenants designed to preserve the community's quality and long-term appeal. Conveniently located just minutes from downtown Monticello, Indiana Beach, shopping, restaurants, and Tippecanoe Country Club, Lakeview Bay is also situated directly across from Pine View Golf Course, providing easy access to many of the area's most popular recreational amenities. Whether you're planning a primary residence or a weekend retreat, these lots offer an outstanding opportunity to build in one of the Lake Shafer area's newest residential communities.

2109 Deepwater, Monticello

Listing courtesy of Michael Lewis from REAL ESTATE NETWORK L.L.C. Cell: 574-581-9962
$75,000
202633412 MLS ⋅ Michael Lewis
Lakeview Bay – Interior Lots with Lake Shafer Access. Build your dream home in Lakeview Bay, an attractive lakeside community in Monticello offering spacious interior homesites with shared access to Lake Shafer through a private community common area and courtesy dock reserved exclusively for homeowners. Situated along the East side of the subdivision, Lot 5 offers an excellent homesite with the potential for attractive backyard views toward Lake Shafer. Enjoy a peaceful setting with convenient access to the community's private lakeside common area and temporary mooring pier for exclusive use by Lakeview Bay homeowners. Enjoy the benefits of lake living without the maintenance or cost of a waterfront lot. These homesites feature access to public utilities, including sewer, water, natural gas, and electric, and are protected by neighborhood covenants designed to preserve the community's quality and long-term appeal. Conveniently located just minutes from downtown Monticello, Indiana Beach, shopping, restaurants, and Tippecanoe Country Club, Lakeview Bay is also situated directly across from Pine View Golf Course, providing easy access to many of the area's most popular recreational amenities. Whether you're planning a primary residence or a weekend retreat, these lots offer an outstanding opportunity to build in one of the Lake Shafer area's newest residential communities.

2115 Deepwater, Monticello

Listing courtesy of Michael Lewis from REAL ESTATE NETWORK L.L.C. Cell: 574-581-9962
$449,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 202633214 MLS ⋅ 2,104 SqFt. ⋅ Sean Dekker
A COZY RETREAT AMIDST LAKE FREEMAN's ELITE! The sky's the limit for this 2100 sf, 3 Bed/2 Bath waterfront home located right in the middle of Lake Freeman's premier neighborhood. The main level features an updated kitchen, dining area, living room w/fireplace, laundry space, a bedroom & a full bath. The 2nd level offers a master bed/bath & a 3rd bedroom which share an XL Jack-n-Jill walk-in closet. Exterior amenities include: 1) a 33' wide covered porch with built-in storage rm, mechanicals rm., whole house generator, & built-in gas lines for BBQ & Firepit needs, 2) Large open patio in the spacious lakeside yard, 3) wide lakeview deck w/stairs or trolly to access the 71' of lakefront with 3 lifts, piers, and of course, LAKE LIFE FUN! Priced & selling 'AS IS'

1007 E Ohio St, Monticello

Listing courtesy of Sean Dekker from REAL ESTATE NETWORK L.L.C.

$216,500
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 202633112 MLS ⋅ 1,748 SqFt. ⋅ Lynn Edgell
Renovated All-Brick home blending classic character with modern updates throughout. The home features all-new flooring, newer windows, two full bathrooms with walk-in showers, french doors, pocket doors, and a gas-log fireplace. The foyer provides an inviting entry, while abundant natural light creates a bright and comfortable atmosphere. The eat-in kitchen features stainless steel appliances, center island, and two side porches for added outdoor living and dining. The large bedroom has a walk-in closet and private balcony. Situated on a large lot, the property also includes a two-car garage and additional parking.

210 N Railroad St, Monticello

Listing courtesy of Lynn Edgell from @properties.

$99,900
202632417 MLS ⋅ John Koppelmann, CRS, e-PRO, GRI, SRES
Enjoy 50 feet of beautiful Tippecanoe River frontage! This riverfront property offers the perfect setting for recreation, relaxation, and enjoying all that the river has to offer. Recent improvements include a new steel seawall, new deck featuring durable Trex decking and metal railing, and a brick paver patio providing excellent outdoor entertaining space. A new storage shed offers convenient storage for boating and recreational equipment, while electric service to the lot adds versatility for future use. Whether you're looking for a weekend getaway, a place to enjoy the river, or a property to build your own retreat, this 50-foot riverfront lot is ready to enjoy!

7759 E Dale Ct, Monticello

Listing courtesy of John Koppelmann, CRS, e-PRO, GRI, SRES from Koppelmann Real Estate. Office: 574-583-3171
$309,900
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 202632348 MLS ⋅ 682 SqFt. ⋅ Michelle Gerhart
Adorable and Updated Lake Freeman Cottage! This beautifully decorated and updated cottage could be yours and is being offered as "turn key" including most of the furnishings and decor you see. Additionally it offers 3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, an open concept living space, stackable W/D, large kitchen island, and gorgeous views. Step outside and enjoy your large 27X19 deck off the living space for entertaining, a permanent covered electric boat and double jet ski lift for your watercrafts, a very nice upper waterfront deck and a shed for storage.

11820 N Vista Dr, Monticello

Listing courtesy of Michelle Gerhart from VOGEL REAL ESTATE. mgerhart@vogel-real-estate.com
$599,900
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 202632311 MLS ⋅ 3,166 SqFt. ⋅ Mary Pomasl
Wake up to the breathtaking views of beautiful Lake Freeman! Nestled on a beautifully wooded 1.45 acres setting consisting of three separate lots. The multiple lot configuration also provides valuable flexibility and future possibilities for the new owner, making this a truly unique Lake Freeman property. This 3166 square foot home offers the perfect blend of comfort, space and year round recreation. Designed for both everyday living and entertaining, the home features 4 spacious bedrooms, 2 full baths and 2 half baths. The desirable main level primary suite provides comfort and convenience, while the inviting family room, complete with a cozy fireplace, creates the perfect gathering space after a day on the lake. The walkout basement offers additional living and entertaining space with easy access to the waterfront. Step outside onto the deck and patio where you'll enjoy spectacular views of Lake Freeman. Ideal setting for morning coffee, outdoor dining or simply relaxing and taking in the water views. Boating enthusiasts will appreciate the included boat lift, making it easy to get out on the lake whenever the mood strikes. Storage is abundant with both an attached 2 car garage and an additional detached 2 car garage, providing plenty of room for vehicles, boats, and all your lake toys. Whether you are searching for a full time residence or the perfect weekend retreat, this rare property offers approximately 1.6 acres across 3 separate lots, privacy, incredible views, and exceptional flexibility for the future all while providing the water lifestyle you've been dreaming of.

5239 E Colonial Oaks Dr, Monticello

Listing courtesy of Mary Pomasl from MPR Realty, LLC. Cell: 574-721-4796
Start Your Search

Updated . Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker of MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information. Some listings have been excluded from this website.