Homes for Sale in New Carlisle, IN | Kimberly Sut Group

Advanced Search Market Reports Home Value Connect

Discover an inviting selection of homes for sale in New Carlisle, Indiana, a charming community where rural tranquility meets convenient access to greater St. Joseph County amenities.Potential homeowners will find diverse properties, from spacious single-family residences to homes nestled on generous lots, ideal for those seeking a peaceful lifestyle.The Kimberly Sut Group specializes in helping buyers navigate the New Carlisle real estate market, ensuring you find the perfect property that aligns with your vision of home ownership.Explore current listings and uncover what makes New Carlisle a sought-after destination for families and individuals alike.

Search New Carlisle, IN by Lifestyle

Search New Carlisle, IN by Price

Search New Carlisle, IN by Bedrooms

Search New Carlisle, IN by Bathrooms

Exploring Homes for Sale in New Carlisle, IN

A Diverse Range of Properties Awaits

The current landscape of homes for sale in New Carlisle, IN, presents a compelling variety of options for every preference.From classic ranches providing comfortable single-story living to expansive two-story residences perfect for growing families, the inventory is rich and varied.Many prospective buyers are drawn to the allure of properties offering significant acreage, providing space for gardens, outbuildings, or simply privacy.Beyond traditional builds, opportunities also arise for those interested in newly constructed homes featuring modern designs and efficiencies, or charming historic houses that offer a glimpse into the area's past.Whether you're searching for a compact starter home or a sprawling estate, New Carlisle has a property to match.

Lifestyle & Community Appeal

Living in New Carlisle offers a distinctive blend of peaceful small-town living with the advantage of being just a short drive from the vibrant urban centers of South Bend and Mishawaka.The community prides itself on its welcoming atmosphere and excellent local schools, making it an ideal location for families.Residents enjoy a slower pace of life, often engaging in outdoor activities facilitated by the area's natural beauty.This serene environment, combined with convenient access to shopping, dining, and employment opportunities in nearby cities, enhances the appeal of homes for sale here, fostering a balanced and fulfilling lifestyle for its inhabitants.

Navigating the New Carlisle Real Estate Market

Finding Your Ideal Home Type

When searching for homes for sale in New Carlisle, IN, identifying your ideal property type is crucial.Those seeking accessible living often explore single-story homes for sale in New Carlisle, valuing their practical layouts.Families frequently prioritize homes with large yards in New Carlisle, providing ample space for children and pets.Furthermore, the market offers various affordable homes in New Carlisle, catering to first-time buyers or those seeking value without compromising on community quality.Whether your preference leans towards a quaint bungalow or a spacious four-bedroom house, the local market provides numerous opportunities to find exactly what you're looking for.

Popular Areas and Property Features

While New Carlisle maintains a cohesive community feel, specific areas offer unique characteristics.Homes located closer to the town center often provide easy access to local shops and services, while properties on the rural outskirts boast expansive views and greater privacy.Many homes for sale feature sought-after amenities such as updated kitchens, spacious master suites, and energy-efficient systems.Properties with detached garages, pole barns, or additional outbuildings are particularly popular among those seeking extra storage or workshop space, reflecting the practical needs of many New Carlisle residents.

Why Choose New Carlisle for Your Next Home?

Education and Family Living

New Carlisle is a community deeply invested in its future, exemplified by its commitment to quality education.Families considering homes for sale in New Carlisle often prioritize access to the well-regarded John Glenn School Corporation, known for its dedicated teachers and comprehensive programs.The safe, tight-knit environment makes it an excellent place for children to grow, fostering a sense of belonging that is increasingly rare in today's fast-paced world.This focus on family-centric values reinforces New Carlisle's reputation as a desirable place to establish roots.

Recreation and Outdoors

For outdoor enthusiasts, New Carlisle is a gateway to abundant recreational opportunities.Just a stone's throw away, Potato Creek State Park offers miles of hiking and biking trails, fishing, boating, and camping, providing year-round enjoyment.The Kankakee River also offers opportunities for fishing and kayaking.Many properties even boast direct access to nature or are situated on larger lots perfect for creating private outdoor havens.This proximity to natural beauty is a significant draw for those looking at homes for sale in New Carlisle, offering a lifestyle rich in fresh air and adventure.

Proximity and Commuter Benefits

One of New Carlisle's strategic advantages is its ideal location.Despite its rural charm, the town offers excellent commuter benefits, with easy access to major highways connecting to South Bend, Michigan City, and LaPorte.This means residents can enjoy the peace of country living while maintaining convenient access to employment centers, healthcare facilities, and cultural attractions in larger nearby cities.The blend of tranquil living and practical connectivity makes homes for sale in New Carlisle an attractive option for a wide array of buyers seeking the best of both worlds.

Newest Homes for Sale in New Carlisle, IN

$579,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 841017 MLS ⋅ 5,162 SqFt. ⋅ Kim Huston

Nestled among mature trees and a breathtaking homesite, this builder-owned custom ranch offers a rare combination of quality craftsmanship and versatile DUAL LIVING SPACE. Set on NEARLY ONE ACRE, this property provides a peaceful sanctuary where privacy and luxury come together (No HOA). When you enter the impressive foyer, you'll appreciate the home's design featuring 9-foot ceilings, rounded drywall corners and panoramic windows.The split open-concept floor plan is ideal. The Primary bedroom has a walk in closet & low threshold shower. The 2nd bedroom is 15x13. The den/music room has a closet that could serve as a 3rd bedroom. At the heart of the home is a stunning kitchen featuring ceramic tile and a remarkable 9' x 3' granite island bar. The kitchen flows into an inviting living room, where a gas fireplace creates a warm gathering space. One of the home's most captivating features is the spectacular 16' x 16' glass-enclosed sunroom. BONUS...there is SEPARATE entrance to An Extraordinary Lower-Level Living designed with flexibility where you will find a COMPLETE SECOND living quarters area. It Features 9-foot ceilings, this space includes a 2nd full kitchen, a family room with a second gas fireplace, two bedrooms, a full bath, laundry area, storage room and is connected to a dual-zoned furnace system. It has a private access through the oversized three-car garage, the lower level is ideal for multi-generational living or guests. Hobbyists will appreciate a 2ND DETACHED 24' x 32' GARAGE too! Whether you're seeking a private retreat, a multi-use estate or simply a home that offers room to entertain AND can bring your 5+ vehicles, this exceptional residence delivers a lifestyle few properties can match. Perfectly positioned near several Parks and the Library. This is minutes from the South Shore Train, Amazon Data Center & Lake Michigan Beach Beaches. A truly one-of-a-kind offering that must be experienced to be fully appreciated.

525 S Filbert Street, New Carlisle

Listing courtesy of Kim Huston from REMAX County Wide 1st.

$579,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 202624442 MLS ⋅ 5,162 SqFt. ⋅ Kim Huston

Nestled among mature trees and a breathtaking homesite, this builder-owned custom ranch offers a rare combination of quality craftsmanship and versatile DUAL LIVING SPACE. Set on a NEARLY ONE ACRE park-like setting, the property provides a peaceful sanctuary where nature, privacy, and luxury come together. (No HOA). From the moment you enter the impressive foyer, you'll appreciate the home's thoughtful design, featuring 9-foot ceilings, rounded drywall corners, panoramic windows and an abundance of natural light. The split open-concept floor plan is ideal for everyday living. The Primary bedroom has a walk in closet & low threshold shower. The 2nd bedroom is 15x13. The den/music room has a closet that could serve as a 3rd bedroom. At the heart of the home is a stunning kitchen featuring ceramic tile and a remarkable 9' x 3' granite island bar. The kitchen flows into the inviting living room where a gas fireplace creates a warm gathering space. One of the home's most captivating features is the spectacular 16' x 16' glass-enclosed sunroom. This exceptional space leads to a balcony deck to relax on while enjoying panoramic views of the woods. BONUS...there is SEPARATE entrance to An Extraordinary Lower-Level Living designed with flexibility where you will find a FINISHED COMPLETE SECOND living quarters. It Features 9-foot ceilings throughout, a 2nd full kitchen, spacious family room with a second gas fireplace, two bedrooms, a full bath, laundry area, storage room and is connected to a dual-zoned furnace system. This has its own private access through the oversized, insulated, finished three-car garage. The lower level is ideal for multi-generational living or guests. This area has its own secluded patio for outdoor leisure. Hobbyists will appreciate a 2ND DETACHED 24' x 32' GARAGE too! Whether you're seeking a private retreat, a multi-use estate or simply a home that offers room to live, entertain AND can bring your 5+ vehicles, this exceptional residence delivers a lifestyle few properties can match. Perfectly positioned near several Parks, the Library and School. This property is minutes from the South Shore Train, Amazon Data Center and Lake Michigan Beach Beaches. A truly one-of-a-kind offering that must be experienced to be fully appreciated.

525 S Filbert Street, New Carlisle

Listing courtesy of Kim Huston from Re/Max County Wide 1st. Cell: 574-532-2128

$430,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 202623915 MLS ⋅ 3,514 SqFt. ⋅ Traci Gaddis

Stunning brick and stone-accented ranch home offering the perfect blend of comfort, style, and functionality. This spacious home features 4 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, and an attached 2-car garage. The primary suite is a true retreat with a large walk-in closet and an impressive tiled walk-in shower. The thoughtfully designed floor plan includes a main-floor laundry room and hardwood flooring throughout the main living areas, with cozy carpet in the bedrooms. One of the main-level bedrooms, featuring French doors, provides the perfect space for a home office, den, or flex room. The expansive kitchen is a dream for cooking and entertaining, offering abundant cabinetry and generous countertop space. Downstairs, the finished basement boasts soaring 9-foot ceilings, incredibly plush carpeting, and a large utility/storage area. Wine closet as well. Step outside to your own private oasis. The beautifully landscaped backyard features a flagstone pathway leading to a stunning stone waterfall and koi pond. With ample space for gardening, entertaining, pets, and outdoor enjoyment, this backyard is sure to impress.

55802 Nature View Drive, New Carlisle

Listing courtesy of Traci Gaddis from Blackrock Real Estate Services. 219-262-0086

$299,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 202623864 MLS ⋅ 2,322 SqFt. ⋅ Alana Boothe

After being lovingly cared for by the same owner for decades, this 3 bedroom, 1.5 bath ranch is ready for its next chapter! On 2.1 acres, this property has the kind of space and features that are becoming harder to find. Inside, you'll find a spacious living room, large dining area, heated three-season room, oversized attached garage, and a full dry basement offering excellent storage and future possibilities. Sliding glass doors connect the three-season room to both the dining area and backyard, creating a comfortable space to relax and enjoy the view year-round. Outside, you'll find mature apple trees, Concord grape vines, a firepit area, a detached one-car garage with water and electric, a storage shed, and plenty of open space for gardening, entertaining, hobbies, or simply enjoying the peaceful surroundings. Recent updates include the furnace, central air, and water heater. If you've been searching for a home with room to breathe, space to work and play, and a property that's been genuinely cared for over the years, this one deserves a look!

6266 N 900 E Road, New Carlisle

Listing courtesy of Alana Boothe from Coldwell Banker Realty. 269-469-3950

$125,900

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 840775 MLS ⋅ 933 SqFt. ⋅ Tamie VanLue

THIS PROPERTY IS BEING SOLD AS-IS Here is your chance to own property which is 6 lots in New Carlisle Indiana, in the New Prairie School System. Located a few miles West of the New Amazon Data Center and the new General Motors Plant. There are 2 structures, they are both being sold as unlivable. The one and only lot on E Tulip is vacant land. Schedule your showing today

7674 N South Bend, New Carlisle

Listing courtesy of Tamie VanLue from Listing Leaders.

$599,900

5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 202622432 MLS ⋅ 3,789 SqFt. ⋅ Dan Kelley

MOTIVATED SELLER! Summertime and the livin' easy — that's the heartbeat of this entertainer's dream home. With over 3,300 sq ft of beautifully designed living space, this 5 bedroom, 3.5 bath two story offers room to grow, room to gather, and room to breathe. From the moment you step inside, the soaring 22 ft ceilings, warm natural light, and inviting gas fireplace set the tone for a home that's meant to be lived in, loved in, and shared. Weekend brunches flow effortlessly from the chef's kitchen — complete with granite counters, black stainless appliances, and a walk in pantry — into the breakfast room and out onto the back deck. It's where laughter drifts across the 14×35 saltwater pool, kids cannonballing while friends gather under the covered patio, and where summer nights stretch long and easy. On quieter days, the main-floor primary suite becomes your sanctuary — spa like, serene, and tucked away from the buzz of the household. Even everyday routines feel elevated thanks to a Magnolia inspired laundry room that makes chores feel almost indulgent. Upstairs, life unfolds in all its stages: three generous bedrooms, a full bath, and a flexible loft perfect for playtime, creativity, or late night study sessions. Downstairs, the 9 ft ceiling lower level becomes the heart of game nights, movie marathons, and cozy winter gatherings, complete with a 5th bedroom, ¾ bath and plenty of storage for ultimate convenience. The 3 car garage with polyurea coated floors, cabinetry and attic access for additional storage keeps everything organized, while the professionally landscaped yard and irrigation system ensure the home looks as effortless as it feels. This is more than a house — it's a place where seasons shift, memories stack, and life feels beautifully balanced. Totally move-in ready and ready to welcome you home.

112 Lavender Court, New Carlisle

Listing courtesy of Dan Kelley from Re/Max County Wide 1st. Cell: 574-876-8601

$289,000

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 202620982 MLS ⋅ 1,302 SqFt. ⋅ Carole Noble

Must See "This Home" is on Dead End Street, Nice and Peaceful! Sit's on .80 acre Home has Tons of Updates from New Drywall to Flooring, Cabinets, Bathroom, Appliance's. Nice Metal Roof, New Deck along with a Barn Style Garage, with upstairs lots of potential. Garage has a Huge, Heated work shop nice office area or just a Great Man Cave! Located minutes from US 20! City Sewer! Just "shy" of being an Acre! New Prarie School"s

308 Bellevue Street, New Carlisle

Listing courtesy of Carole Noble from KOONTZ LAKE REALTY. 574-286-0598

$630,000

3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 839918 MLS ⋅ 3,476 SqFt. ⋅ Zachary Spoljoric

Welcome to your dream home! This stunning 3 bedroom, 3.5 bathroom ranch sits on 5.5 gorgeous wooded acres in a desirable neighborhood with a top-rated school system. Inside you'll find an open floor plan with hardwood floors, high ceilings, and plenty of space to entertain. The kitchen features granite counters, maple cabinets, a center island, breakfast bar, and gas range. The spacious primary suite includes a grand bathroom design with dual vanity, shower, and soaking tub. The finished basement is a game-changer. Think rec room, home gym, craft space, and a full bath for guests. Now for the backyard, an in-ground pool with a slide and a large concrete patio make this the ultimate summer hangout. All of this tucked away on 5.5 private acres with mature trees and split-rail fencing. Country living with neighborhood charm. What are you waiting for? Come see it before it's gone!

55220 Sundance Drive, New Carlisle

Listing courtesy of Zachary Spoljoric from RE/MAX Diamond Properties.

$255,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 202620680 MLS ⋅ 1,150 SqFt. ⋅ Tariq Suboh

In Hudson Lake Beach Subdivision this 2-bedroom, 1.5-bathroom home puts you just steps from one of the region's all-sports lakes. Hudson Lake spans 423 acres with a maximum depth of 39 feet, offering a full day of boating, jet skiing, wakeboarding, and water skiing. At dusk, the lake transitions to no-wake, making evenings on the water as peaceful as the days are thrilling. The renovated bathroom is a true showpiece, featuring a ceramic tile shower, rainfall shower head, glass door, and a skylight that floods the space with natural light. The primary bedroom offers a warm, custom feel with a handcrafted feature wall that anchors the room, plus custom built-ins in the closet that maximize every inch of storage. Step outside onto the large deck off the back of the home — the perfect place to unwind after a day on the lake. Whether you're grilling with friends or simply watching the sun dip below the tree line, this outdoor space captures everything that makes lake living so special. Car enthusiasts, hobbyists, and anyone who needs serious workspace will be blown away by the garage setup built in 2017. The property includes three bays of garage space: a main garage at 28x25, a second bay at 23x16, and a third bay at 23x21 that features heated floors, painted concrete, and 200-amp electric service — ready for a workshop, collector cars, or whatever your passion demands. Location couldn't be more convenient. South Bend is just 15 miles away — approximately a 20-minute drive — putting dining, shopping, healthcare, and entertainment right at your fingertips. The University of Notre Dame is just minutes beyond that. And for those who need big-city access, Chicago is approximately 78 miles away, roughly a 90-minute drive — making this an ideal full-time residence or weekend retreat for city dwellers craving the lake life. Don't miss your chance to own in this lakeside community.

7746 N Hudson Boulevard, New Carlisle

Listing courtesy of Tariq Suboh from Ellsbury Group. 219-200-5133

$475,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 202620238 MLS ⋅ 3,534 SqFt. ⋅ Julie Circle

Come see for yourself. Seller is ready to turn over the keys! Spacious, light-filled 4 bedroom, 3 bath ranch offered by the original owner/builder! (Possible fifth bedroom in lower) This thoughtfully designed home feels open, airy, and welcoming from the moment you enter through the double front doors. The open-concept kitchen, dining, and living areas create an easy flow for everyday living and entertaining, while numerous Andersen sliding glass doors frame peaceful views and bring in abundant natural light.The split-bedroom floor plan offers excellent privacy for the primary suite, featuring a walk-in closet, extra-wide walk-in shower, double sinks, bidet, and a calm, comfortable layout. Tray ceilings and indirect lighting add warmth and architectural interest throughout many rooms, complemented by neutral carpet and tile flooring. Enjoy flexible wide living spaces, including French doors to a guest room, an office or third bedroom on the main level, and a finished lower level with an egress window, kitchenette, fourth bedroom, full bath and an additional room complete with emergency supplies. Outdoor living is easy with a composite deck, covered back porch, irrigation system, storage shed with electric, established apple trees and tranquil backyard views. Nature enthusiasts will swoon. Car enthusiasts, hobbyists, or those needing extra workspace will love the heated workshop located in the third and fourth garage bays. With no HOA, generous living space, and thoughtful custom features throughout, this one-owner ranch offers comfort, function, and flexibility in a peaceful setting.

609 S Bray Street, New Carlisle

Listing courtesy of Julie Circle from Keller Williams Realty Group. myhomebrokerjulie@gmail.com

$15,167,750

202618940 MLS ⋅ Stephen Smith

Discover the potential of this expansive 233-acre property, featuring two pole barns and set against the scenic backdrop of New Carlisle. Ideally located near the upcoming battery plant, this land offers endless opportunities for development. Envision a peaceful residential community that blends modern amenities with tranquil country living. Whether you're an investor, developer, or visionary, this property provides a prime canvas to bring your ideas to life. Call today to explore the possibilities!

Vl Nw Corner Spruce Rd & Chicago Trail, New Carlisle

Listing courtesy of Stephen Smith from Irish Realty. steve.smith@irishrealty.net

$399,999

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 838988 MLS ⋅ 1,796 SqFt. ⋅ Angela Pritchard

Welcome home to to this beautifully maintained 3 bedroom, 2.5 bath residence situated on a spacious 1.81 acre parcel in one of the areas sought-after subdivisions. So many amenities but the whole house generator is on the top of the list. Offering the perfect blend of privacy and neighborhood living, this property features a picturesque setting with plenty of room to relax, entertain and enjoy the outdoors. Inside you'll find a well-designed floor plan with generous living spaces, a bright and inviting kitchen, and comfortable bedrooms including a spacious primary suite with private bath. The home has been lovingly cared for and offers ideal combination of functionality and charm. Step outside to enjoy the expansive yard, mature landscaping and peaceful surroundings. The home has had the ducts cleaned and added a blue light on the furnace for allergens.

33671 Woodmont Ridge Drive, New Carlisle

Listing courtesy of Angela Pritchard from Addresses Unlimited, LLC.

Start Your Search

Prev
1
2
3
...
9
of 9
Next

IDX information is provided by the Indiana Regional MLS and is exclusively for the consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS.

Last updated

Updated . Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.