Homes for Sale in New Carlisle, IN | Kimberly Sut Group

Advanced Search Market Reports Home Value Connect

Discover an inviting selection of homes for sale in New Carlisle, Indiana, a charming community where rural tranquility meets convenient access to greater St. Joseph County amenities.Potential homeowners will find diverse properties, from spacious single-family residences to homes nestled on generous lots, ideal for those seeking a peaceful lifestyle.The Kimberly Sut Group specializes in helping buyers navigate the New Carlisle real estate market, ensuring you find the perfect property that aligns with your vision of home ownership.Explore current listings and uncover what makes New Carlisle a sought-after destination for families and individuals alike.

Search New Carlisle, IN by Lifestyle

Search New Carlisle, IN by Price

Search New Carlisle, IN by Bedrooms

Search New Carlisle, IN by Bathrooms

Exploring Homes for Sale in New Carlisle, IN

A Diverse Range of Properties Awaits

The current landscape of homes for sale in New Carlisle, IN, presents a compelling variety of options for every preference.From classic ranches providing comfortable single-story living to expansive two-story residences perfect for growing families, the inventory is rich and varied.Many prospective buyers are drawn to the allure of properties offering significant acreage, providing space for gardens, outbuildings, or simply privacy.Beyond traditional builds, opportunities also arise for those interested in newly constructed homes featuring modern designs and efficiencies, or charming historic houses that offer a glimpse into the area's past.Whether you're searching for a compact starter home or a sprawling estate, New Carlisle has a property to match.

Lifestyle & Community Appeal

Living in New Carlisle offers a distinctive blend of peaceful small-town living with the advantage of being just a short drive from the vibrant urban centers of South Bend and Mishawaka.The community prides itself on its welcoming atmosphere and excellent local schools, making it an ideal location for families.Residents enjoy a slower pace of life, often engaging in outdoor activities facilitated by the area's natural beauty.This serene environment, combined with convenient access to shopping, dining, and employment opportunities in nearby cities, enhances the appeal of homes for sale here, fostering a balanced and fulfilling lifestyle for its inhabitants.

Navigating the New Carlisle Real Estate Market

Finding Your Ideal Home Type

When searching for homes for sale in New Carlisle, IN, identifying your ideal property type is crucial.Those seeking accessible living often explore single-story homes for sale in New Carlisle, valuing their practical layouts.Families frequently prioritize homes with large yards in New Carlisle, providing ample space for children and pets.Furthermore, the market offers various affordable homes in New Carlisle, catering to first-time buyers or those seeking value without compromising on community quality.Whether your preference leans towards a quaint bungalow or a spacious four-bedroom house, the local market provides numerous opportunities to find exactly what you're looking for.

Popular Areas and Property Features

While New Carlisle maintains a cohesive community feel, specific areas offer unique characteristics.Homes located closer to the town center often provide easy access to local shops and services, while properties on the rural outskirts boast expansive views and greater privacy.Many homes for sale feature sought-after amenities such as updated kitchens, spacious master suites, and energy-efficient systems.Properties with detached garages, pole barns, or additional outbuildings are particularly popular among those seeking extra storage or workshop space, reflecting the practical needs of many New Carlisle residents.

Why Choose New Carlisle for Your Next Home?

Education and Family Living

New Carlisle is a community deeply invested in its future, exemplified by its commitment to quality education.Families considering homes for sale in New Carlisle often prioritize access to the well-regarded John Glenn School Corporation, known for its dedicated teachers and comprehensive programs.The safe, tight-knit environment makes it an excellent place for children to grow, fostering a sense of belonging that is increasingly rare in today's fast-paced world.This focus on family-centric values reinforces New Carlisle's reputation as a desirable place to establish roots.

Recreation and Outdoors

For outdoor enthusiasts, New Carlisle is a gateway to abundant recreational opportunities.Just a stone's throw away, Potato Creek State Park offers miles of hiking and biking trails, fishing, boating, and camping, providing year-round enjoyment.The Kankakee River also offers opportunities for fishing and kayaking.Many properties even boast direct access to nature or are situated on larger lots perfect for creating private outdoor havens.This proximity to natural beauty is a significant draw for those looking at homes for sale in New Carlisle, offering a lifestyle rich in fresh air and adventure.

Proximity and Commuter Benefits

One of New Carlisle's strategic advantages is its ideal location.Despite its rural charm, the town offers excellent commuter benefits, with easy access to major highways connecting to South Bend, Michigan City, and LaPorte.This means residents can enjoy the peace of country living while maintaining convenient access to employment centers, healthcare facilities, and cultural attractions in larger nearby cities.The blend of tranquil living and practical connectivity makes homes for sale in New Carlisle an attractive option for a wide array of buyers seeking the best of both worlds.

Newest Homes for Sale in New Carlisle, IN

$243,500

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 202627419 MLS ⋅ 2,044 SqFt. ⋅ Jeremy Williamson

**MULTIPLE OFFERS -- Deadline for submission of offer is 7PM CST, Saturday, 7/11. Expiration set for 4PM CST, Sunday, 7/12/26.Completely renovated and move-in ready, this 3-bedroom, 2-bath home in the New Prairie School District is ready for its next owner! From the moment you step inside, you'll appreciate the extensive updates, including new carpet, laminate flooring, updated bathrooms, new lighting, kitchen countertops, appliances, front and back decks, and so much more. The spacious eat-in kitchen features a large pantry, making everyday living and entertaining easy. The primary bedroom offers a private ensuite, while the additional bedrooms provide flexibility for guests, a home office, or other needs. Downstairs, the partially finished basement adds even more usable space with a bar area, plus abundant storage throughout the home. Outside, you'll enjoy a nicely sized, fenced backyard with plenty of room to relax, entertain, or let your pets roam. The oversized 2-car garage includes a dedicated workbench area for projects, hobbies, or extra storage. Conveniently located near New Prairie Junior and Senior High School, this home offers the updates, space, and location you've been looking for. With nothing left to do but move in, all that's missing is you.

7095 E Us Highway 20, New Carlisle

Listing courtesy of Jeremy Williamson from McKinnies Realty, LLC. Cell: 574-261-5703

$335,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 202626966 MLS ⋅ 2,968 SqFt. ⋅ Traci Gaddis

Welcome to New Carlisle Nice Place to Visit. A Great Place to Live. Exceptionally well-maintained 3-bedroom, 1¾-bath home situated on a desirable corner lot in New Carlisle! Pride of ownership shines throughout this spotless, move-in-ready property. The spacious primary suite features a private ¾ en-suite bath, while the finished basement offers the perfect space to entertain with a custom-built solid wood bar and a gym that will blow you away. Enjoy the oversized vaulted 3-season room with electricity—ideal for relaxing, entertaining, or creating your favorite hobby space. The heated garage includes an electric vehicle charger outlet , and both outdoor sheds are equipped with electricity, providing exceptional convenience and functionality. Quality craftsmanship, meticulous care, and timeless character make this home truly stand out. Homes like this are hard to find—don't miss your opportunity to make it yours! Schedule your private showing today

317 E Ben Street, New Carlisle

Listing courtesy of Traci Gaddis from Blackrock Real Estate Services. 219-262-0086

$379,900

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 841793 MLS ⋅ 2,842 SqFt. ⋅ Kristy Ruminski

Beautifully updated and move-in ready, this spacious home is tucked away on a quiet cul-de-sac in the desirable New Prairie School District. Offering four bedrooms and three full bathrooms, the flexible floor plan is designed to accommodate a variety of lifestyles, including the option for two private primary suites. The heart of the home features an open and airy layout where the kitchen, dining, and living spaces come together, creating the perfect setting for everyday living and effortless entertaining. A conveniently located main-level laundry room provides abundant storage and keeps daily tasks organized and within easy reach. The finished lower level adds an incredible amount of additional living space and is currently being utilized as a luxurious primary suite. This versatile area includes a spacious walk-in closet, a beautifully appointed en-suite bathroom with a tiled walk-in shower, a stunning tiled feature wall with an electric fireplace, and plenty of room to customize the space to fit your needs. Whether you envision a private owner's retreat, family room, game room, or guest quarters, this level offers endless possibilities. Thoughtful updates throughout the home create a warm, inviting atmosphere while blending style and functionality. Outside, you'll love the fully fenced backyard, offering plenty of space for children, pets, gardening, or hosting family and friends. An attached two-car garage provides excellent storage and convenience, while the peaceful cul-de-sac location offers a quiet setting with very little traffic. If you've been searching for a home that offers generous living space, modern updates, and a fantastic location, this one is ready to welcome you home.

201 E Compton Street, New Carlisle

Listing courtesy of Kristy Ruminski from Brokerworks Group.

$399,000

5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 841630 MLS ⋅ 3,905 SqFt. ⋅ Daniel Kelley

Step into timeless character in this beautifully maintained 5 bedroom, 3 bath home located in the heart of downtown New Carlisle. Offering 2,696 finished sq. feet above ground and that doesn't include the full sized finished basement. This spacious residence showcases stunning original hardwood floors, rich architectural detail and the kind of old-world charm that's impossible to replicate. Updates include new water heater, roof (5 yrs), furnace and a/c unit (1 yr), water line and a new electrical panel. From the moment you arrive, you'll appreciate the inviting curb appeal, oversized living spaces, and warmth throughout every room. The thoughtfully designed layout provides ample space for entertaining, relaxing, or accommodating a growing household, while the detached 2 car-garage adds everyday convenience. Perfectly situated near local shops, dining, parks, and community events, this home blends historic elegance with small-town charm in one of New Carlisle's most desirable locations. A rare opportunity to own a piece of character-filled craftsmanship with the space and functionality today's buyers are looking for. Schedule your showing today- you won't be disappointed!

222 W Michigan Street, New Carlisle

Listing courtesy of Daniel Kelley from REMAX County Wide 1st.

$4,602,500

841469 MLS ⋅ Kim Huston

*PRIME PROPERTY* A rare opportunity within IEC (Indiana Enterprise Center) and Master Planned Industrial Park in Olive Township, New Carlisle. Currently zoned AG. Surrounding properties are Zoned Commercial or Industrial and all within the Commericial District. Neighboring businesses are St. Joseph Energy Center, Cleveland Cliffs, Amazon Data Center and the GM Plant. This Central Midwest location is Accessibile to Interstates, Fiber Optic Internet, and adjacent to Water and Sewer Utilities infrastructure. This could be your last potential option to own a site in this established growing area with endless possibilites. Broker owned.

31890 Edison Road, New Carlisle

Listing courtesy of Kim Huston from REMAX County Wide 1st.

$4,602,500

202625842 MLS ⋅ Kim Huston

31890 Edison Road, New Carlisle

Listing courtesy of Kim Huston from Re/Max County Wide 1st. Cell: 574-532-2128

$459,900

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 202625813 MLS ⋅ 5,134 SqFt. ⋅ Kyle Lechlitner

Beautiful one-owner sprawling ranch on a half-acre lot offering space, comfort, and thoughtful construction throughout. This 4-bedroom, 3 full-bath home features a large great room with cathedral ceilings that creates an open, airy feel in the main living area. With plenty of living space on both levels, there is room for everyday living, entertaining, and multi-generational flexibility. Beautiful one-owner sprawling ranch situated on a half-acre lot with peaceful country views, quality construction, and exceptional space for everyday living and entertaining. This 4-bedroom, 3 full-bath home welcomes you with a spacious great room featuring cathedral ceilings and an open, airy feel throughout the main living area. The finished lower level offers over 2,200 square feet of additional finished living space, complete with a full second kitchen - ideal for entertaining, extended living arrangements, or extra cooking space. You'll also find a 4th bedroom with an egress window, plus a 5th potential bedroom that could be easily completed by adding an egress window. Car enthusiasts, hobbyists, and anyone needing extra workspace will appreciate the heated garage and the attached 11x11 heated and cooled workshop, offering comfort and versatility year-round. Major updates provide peace of mind, including a new roof in April 2026, new HVAC in 2024, water softener in 2026, and water heater in 2020. ADT Security system is wired and ready to activate. Additional highlights include 2x6 exterior walls, insulated interior walls, a generous backyard with full irrigation system, and a new composite deck added in 2024 - the perfect place to relax and take in the country setting.

32794 Nature View Drive, New Carlisle

Listing courtesy of Kyle Lechlitner from Trueblood Real Estate. 574-204-2676

$145,000

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 841343 MLS ⋅ 552 SqFt. ⋅ Kevin Srednoselac

Welcome to this charming 2-bedroom, 1-bath home offering an affordable opportunity in the Hudson Lake area! Situated on a spacious 10,000-square-foot lot, this property provides plenty of room to enjoy the outdoors, entertain, garden, or expand your vision. Inside, you'll find a functional layout that maximizes the home's space, making it ideal for first-time homebuyers, investors, airbnb opportunities, or anyone looking to downsize. Convert the unfinished porch space into more living space or enjoy it as a flex room. Conveniently located with easy access to local amenities and major roadways, this property combines small-town living with everyday convenience. Whether you're looking for a place to call home or an investment opportunity, this property is full of potential. Schedule your private showing today and imagine the possibilities!

7956 N Elder Lane, New Carlisle

Listing courtesy of Kevin Srednoselac from Absolute Realty Solutions LLC.

$315,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 202625029 MLS ⋅ 2,548 SqFt. ⋅ Steve Weldy

Well-maintained 3 bedroom, 2 full bath ranch situated on a beautiful 2-acre lot in the popular New Prairie School District. The spacious living room features a large picture window and flows into the dining area, where a sliding glass door provides views of the expansive backyard. The primary bedroom includes a private attached bath. Accessibility features include two walk-in showers including an ADA-compliant hall bath with a wide vanity and quartz countertop. Newer windows and siding add to the home's appeal. The full unfinished basement offers potential additional living space and flexibility for recreation, or hobbies. Enjoy peaceful country living with a large backyard that backs up to a farm field, providing privacy and no rear neighbors. Relax on the patio and take in the rural setting while still being just minutes from downtown New Carlisle, shopping, and restaurants. An oversized 2-car garage and storage shed provide plenty of room for vehicles, tools, and outdoor equipment. Measurements and square footage are approximate. Buyer to verity school assignment.

6384 N 900 E Road, New Carlisle

Listing courtesy of Steve Weldy from Weichert Rltrs-J.Dunfee&Assoc.. 574-277-7444

$469,900

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 202624696 MLS ⋅ 2,718 SqFt. ⋅ Stephen Smith

Beautifully maintained two-story home situated on a large lot in desirable Stone Oak Estates, offering a convenient location just minutes from down town New Carlisle. The attractive curb appeal is enhanced by mature landscaping and well-kept grounds, creating a welcoming first impression. Step inside to discover spacious living areas filled with natural light and an open, functional layout ideal for both everyday living and entertaining. The kitchen features a center island with breakfast bar seating, tile backsplash, soft-close cabinetry, and a large walk-in pantry, all flowing seamlessly into the main living space. Upstairs, the generous primary suite boasts cathedral ceilings, a spacious walk-in closet, and a private bath with dual-sink vanity. Two additional bedrooms, a full bath, and a conveniently located laundry room complete the second floor. Additional highlights include abundant storage throughout, a practical mudroom, main-floor half bath, and a beautifully landscaped yard with plenty of room to enjoy outdoor living. There is a promotion running where Seller and HMA are offering to contribute $1,000 each towards closing cost on this spec home if financing is obtained through HMA Mortgage. There is nothing left for you to do except move in so don't wait - schedule your showing today!

32811 Nature View Drive, New Carlisle

Listing courtesy of Stephen Smith from Irish Realty. steve.smith@irishrealty.net

$399,000

5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 202624688 MLS ⋅ 4,134 SqFt. ⋅ Halee Woods

Open House Saturday 7/25 @ 1-3 E.T. Step into timeless character in this beautifully maintained 5 bedroom, 3 bath home located in the heart of downtown New Carlisle. Offering 2,696 finished sq. feet above ground and that doesn't include the full sized finished basement. This spacious residence showcases stunning original hardwood floors, rich architectural detail and the kind of old-world charm that's impossible to replicate. Updates include new water heater, roof (5 yrs), furnace and a/c unit (1 yr), water line and a new electrical panel. From the moment you arrive, you'll appreciate the inviting curb appeal, oversized living spaces, and warmth throughout every room. The thoughtfully designed layout provides ample space for entertaining, relaxing, or accommodating a growing household, while the detached 2 car-garage adds everyday convenience. Perfectly situated near local shops, dining, parks, and community events, this home blends historic elegance with small-town charm in one of New Carlisle's most desirable locations. A rare opportunity to own a piece of character-filled craftsmanship with the space and functionality today's buyers are looking for. Schedule your showing today- you won't be disappointed!

222 W Michigan Street, New Carlisle

Listing courtesy of Halee Woods from Re/Max County Wide 1st. Cell: 574-261-0181

$60,000

202624470 MLS ⋅ Jan Lazzara

Opportunity awaits in the heart of downtown New Carlisle! Located on historic Lincoln Way and right on the Town Square, this approximately 1,700 sq. ft. building sits in the center of a charming downtown district surrounded by shops, restaurants, boutiques, coffee houses, and local businesses, with the fire station directly across the street. The interior has been gutted and is ready for a complete renovation, offering a blank canvas for your vision. Whether you’re looking to create a retail shop, studio, office, or another business venture, the possibilities are endless. Bring your ideas and transform this property into something special. An affordable opportunity to invest in one of New Carlisle’s most visible locations!

207 E Michigan Street, New Carlisle

Listing courtesy of Jan Lazzara from RE/MAX 100. Cell: 574-532-8001

Start Your Search

Prev
1
2
3
...
9
of 9
Next

IDX information is provided by the Indiana Regional MLS and is exclusively for the consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS.

Last updated

Updated . Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.