Rensselaer Homes for Sale

Welcome to Rensselaer, Indiana—a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Jasper County. This charming city, steeped in rich history and small-town allure, is the perfect place for families, retirees, and anyone seeking a peaceful lifestyle without compromising on convenience. With its strategic location just off Interstate 65, Rensselaer offers easy access to larger metropolitan areas while maintaining its quaint, rural charm.

Rensselaer boasts a vibrant community atmosphere, where friendly faces greet you at local shops, family-run restaurants, and community events that bring residents together. The city is home to beautiful parks, well-maintained walking trails, and recreational facilities, making it an ideal spot for outdoor enthusiasts. Whether you’re enjoying a summer picnic at the picturesque Brookside Park or exploring the historic downtown district, Rensselaer invites you to embrace a slower pace of life.

For those looking to make Rensselaer their home, the real estate market offers a variety of options to suit diverse needs and budgets. From charming single-family homes with spacious yards to cozy bungalows and modern townhouses, there’s something for everyone. With competitive pricing and a welcoming community, now is the perfect time to explore homes for sale in this delightful city.

Imagine waking up in a place where neighbors become friends and every day feels like a community celebration. Rensselaer, Indiana, is not just a place to live; it’s a place to thrive. Discover your next home in Rensselaer and experience the warmth and charm this city has to offer!

Newest Rensselaer Homes for Sale

$179,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 845187 MLS ⋅ 1,344 SqFt. ⋅ Laura Eenigenburg

This 4 Bedroom 2 bath Ranch is ready for your updating touches. This home is 1344 square ft with 4 nice sized bedrooms. Generously sized living room with new flooring and eat-in kitchen with plenty of room for cooking and entertaining. Enclosed porch on the back to relax & watch the wildlife. The garage has a center drain & heater so you can wash your cars even during the winter. Peaceful and quiet private back yard. Priced in consideration of work needed to be done. Schedule your private showing today.

789 County Rd 225 N, Rensselaer

Listing courtesy of Laura Eenigenburg from RE/MAX Executives.

$178,900

1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 845123 MLS ⋅ 832 SqFt. ⋅ JoAnn McElfresh

This home is like new. Striped to the studs 3 years ago. New windows, insulation, plumbing, electric, heating and cooling, roof, siding, drywall, cabinets, bathroom, lighting, doors, flooring and appliances are all only 3 years old. Enter the open concept living room that flows in the the beautiful kitchen with large sink, fridge, 5 burner gas stove with microwave, and dishwasher. There is also a large pantry for more storage. The 2 bedrooms have large closets and carpet flooring. Sliding barn door leads to the laundry room which is equipped with washer, dryer and storage cabinets and a door to the back yard to the detached garage with concrete floors. Don't miss out on this great home that you will be able to enjoy for years to come.

418 E Oak Street, Rensselaer

Listing courtesy of JoAnn McElfresh from Jenkins Real Estate, Inc..

$239,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 845023 MLS ⋅ 2,170 SqFt. ⋅ Trisha Potts

Step into the character and charm of this classic two-story home, originally built in 1913. Offering 3 bedrooms with the possibility of a fourth and two full bathrooms, this home provides flexible living space while still showcasing the timeless details that give an older home its unique appeal. With plenty of room to make it your own, the layout offers versatility for an additional bedroom, home office, or bonus space. Outside, you will find a partially fenced yard with space to relax, entertain, or play. A detached garage provides convenient parking along with bonus storage for tools , lawn equipment, hobbies, and more. If you're looking for a home with history, character, and functional space both inside and out, this one is ready for its new chapter! Call an agent today!

737 N College Avenue, Rensselaer

Listing courtesy of Trisha Potts from RE/MAX Executives.

$149,900

844393 MLS ⋅ JoAnn McElfresh

Where are my fixer uppers? This almost 2000 sf home on 2 acres has so much potential. Home has already been lifted and a new concrete foundation poured. Home has new metal roof made to resemble cedar shake shingles. It is a sold home just waiting for you to put your creative vision in it. Some materials are included. Seller has appliances for the home that will remain with the property. The old fieldstone front porch pillars are still standing waiting for completion. The interior stairway is beautiful with intricate detailing. Home is under construction.

569 S 100 W, Rensselaer

Listing courtesy of JoAnn McElfresh from Jenkins Real Estate, Inc..

$169,000

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 844358 MLS ⋅ 1,441 SqFt. ⋅ Suzanne Soto

This cute little starter home near the heart of Rensselaer is a great solution to renting and is ready for its next owners. The main floor has a nice open living area that leads into the dining and kitchen with a bedroom on the main floor. A nice sized laundry room and mud room is at the back of the home. Upstairs has two additional nice sized bedrooms as well. The back yard is completely fenced in for privacy including a small shed. This home is being sold as is and the seller is offering 5,000 toward the replacement of the bathtub as it is currently non functioning and has a hole in the bottom no fault of the current seller. Come see if this home checks your boxes today!!! Invest in yourself!!!

113 E Vine Street, Rensselaer

Listing courtesy of Suzanne Soto from RE/MAX Executives.

$725,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 844216 MLS ⋅ 5,704 SqFt. ⋅ Terri Phegley

Stunning Home sitting on 3.37 acres in the city limits! This home has city utilities, is close to amenities and I-65 for an easy commute! This home boasts Brazilian Cherry Hardwood Floors, Vaulted Ceilings, Wet Bar and Custom Entertainment Center. French Doors open out to the charming Veranda with Ceiling Fans. The Beautiful Kitchen features Cherry Cabinets, Granite Counters, Marble Backsplash and Built-In Pantry. 4 Generous Bedrooms, 2 on each floor, and 4 Baths. The finished basement adds amazing space to this Lovely Home! There is plenty of storage for your toys, collections or cars in the 2 Car Garage (14 x 24), 4 Bay Heated Garage (30 x 45) with bath and the 36 x 70 Quonset that is heated in the back and cooled with a window AC. Bring your RV as there is a door to pull it right in the Quonset and hook it up! Enjoy the Fenced Yard with Large Patio. Gated for Privacy, this home offers a blend of Elegance, Comfort and Convenience. This exceptional home is ready for viewing. Proof of funds or lender pre-approval is requested prior to scheduling.

827 W Clark Street, Rensselaer

Listing courtesy of Terri Phegley from Cornerstone Real Estate Agency.

$390,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 844135 MLS ⋅ 2,312 SqFt. ⋅ Terri Phegley

Distinctive 1970s contemporary ranch with Mid-Century Modern influence. There's something about this home that makes you want to slow down and stay awhile. Start your morning on the open front porch, coffee in hand, enjoying the peaceful setting across from Curtis Creek Golf Course. Watch the leaves change, Spiring bloom and the snow cover this Beautiful Golf Course. Spend an afternoon on the expansive back patio (with Vaulted Gabled Roof outside the living room) beneath the mature trees, and when the seasons change, bring the gathering indoors beside one of two fireplaces. Natural light is part of the experience here. An abundance of windows and five sets of French patio doors create a wonderful connection between the indoors and out, filling the home with sunshine and views of the beautiful surroundings. Thoughtful updates including new flooring, newer central air and a whole-house generator add comfort and peace of mind, while the spacious floor plan gives you room to live, entertain and simply enjoy home. It's peaceful, welcoming and just a little unexpected. You might even catch a black squirrel darting through the trees. Come experience this one for yourself--you may find it feels like home before you ever reach the front door. This home is in an Estate and sellers welcome home inspections; however, the home is sold as-is.

5910 S 1080 W, Rensselaer

Listing courtesy of Terri Phegley from Cornerstone Real Estate Agency.

$464,900

5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 844020 MLS ⋅ 5,274 SqFt. ⋅ JoAnn McElfresh

Prime Location! This home is right next door to the playground for St Augustine School and walking distance to downtown. Originally a small 1940s house, the home was purchased in 2000 and rebuilt to add over 4000 sq. feet of new living space. Enjoy some of the character and charm when you step onto the covered front porch and enter into the sitting room with original hardwood floors. A short walk down the hall to the large primary bedroom with gas log insert in the homes original brick fireplace. The attached bathroom is spacious with heated floors. The large kitchen contains lots of cabinets and counters along with a huge island, built-in appliances, and a pantry that any cook would desire. The kitchen is open to a large dining room and beautiful deck that opens to the backyard. The large living room is also open to both spaces and separated by a built-in three sided gas log fireplace. The spacious laundry room is on the main level next to the oversized garage. The upstairs includes three very generous bedrooms, a full bathroom to share, and lots of open space for recreation. Large visiting families can easily be accommodated, given the space and second floor thermostat control. The basement is well lit and was recently used for a workshop. Two furnaces and two ac units are used to heat and cool this home and are zoned for upstairs and downstairs. They were new in 2020.

413 N Weston Street, Rensselaer

Listing courtesy of JoAnn McElfresh from Jenkins Real Estate, Inc..

$255,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 202633121 MLS ⋅ 1,804 SqFt. ⋅ Kellie Dussault

Welcome to this charming Rensselaer home offering 4 bedrooms and 1.5 baths. Built in 1910, this home combines classic character with plenty of space for everyday living. The main level features a spacious living room, dining room, family room with a gas fireplace, eat-in kitchen, laundry room, and convenient mud room. A large all-seasons room surrounded by windows provides a bright and inviting space to enjoy year-round. Upstairs, you'll find four bedrooms offering flexibility for family, guests, or a home office. Outside, enjoy the generously sized 0.31-acre lot featuring a stamped concrete patio, vinyl privacy fence, screened gazebo, and two storage sheds with electricity. The detached, heated 2-car garage offers alley access, a garage door opener, and even includes a 3/4 bath and utility sink, making it an exceptional bonus space for hobbies, projects, or additional storage. With its combination of character, functional spaces, and impressive outdoor amenities, this home has so much to offer. Don't miss the opportunity to make this Rensselaer gem your own!

1017 N Weston St, Rensselaer

Listing courtesy of Kellie Dussault from Keller Williams Lafayette. Agt: 463-239-0965

$79,500

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 843812 MLS ⋅ 1,340 SqFt. ⋅ Nicole Mathew

LOOK AT WHAT IT COULD BE! She may not be winning any beauty contests yet, but give her some attention and she could be a showstopper! This 1340 sq. ft. fixer-upper is waiting for a glow-up. It's the opportunity for an investor, renovator, or buyer looking to create a home tailored to their own style. The home is being offered in its current condition and will require updates and improvements. Whether you're looking for your next investment project or a chance to build equity through renovation, this property is ready for its next chapter. BRING THIS ONE BACK TO LIFE! Property sold AS IS and CASH ONLY.

1111 N Mckinley Avenue, Rensselaer

Listing courtesy of Nicole Mathew from RE/MAX Executives.

$315,000

5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 843776 MLS ⋅ 1,904 SqFt. ⋅ Trisha Potts

Welcome home to this beautifully remodeled two-story home, where timeless character meets modern convenience. Thoughtfully updated from top to bottom, this spacious property offers five bedrooms, three full baths, and a flexible floor plan designed to fit today's lifestyle. The main floor primary suite provides comfort and privacy, while the additional bedrooms upstairs offer plenty of room for family, guests, or hobbies. Need a dedicated workspace? The private home office is perfect for remote work, studying, or managing day to day tasks. At the heart of the home, you will find a stunning new kitchen featuring granite counter tops, brand new appliances, and ample cabinet space-ready for everything from casual meals to holiday gatherings. Fresh updates throughout the home provide peace of mind while preserving the charm of this classic two story design. An attached garage adds everyday convenience, and for added confidence, the seller is including a one year home warranty for the new owners peace of mind. Don't miss this opportunity to own a move-in ready home that offers the perfect blend of charm, convenience, modern updates and generous living space. Call an agent today!

127 S Park Avenue, Rensselaer

Listing courtesy of Trisha Potts from RE/MAX Executives.

$95,000

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 843407 MLS ⋅ 822 SqFt. ⋅ Keri Hir

Charming 2-bedroom, 1-bath home offering 822 sq ft of comfortable living space in Rensselaer. This well-maintained property features updated plumbing, refreshed electrical throughout the home, and an updated bathroom with a convenient walk-in shower. The kitchen has been recently updated with refreshed cabinets and paint, while the living room offers a fresh coat of paint. Enjoy a solid foundation, a detached one-car garage with workspace, and a great opportunity to add your personal finishing touches

713 N Abigail Street, Rensselaer

Listing courtesy of Keri Hir from Keri Hir.

Start Your Search

Updated . Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker of MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information. Some listings have been excluded from this website.