Monterey Real Estate

Welcome to Monterey, Indiana – a hidden gem nestled in the heart of the Midwest! This charming small town offers a unique blend of rural tranquility and community spirit, making it an ideal place for those seeking a peaceful lifestyle away from the hustle and bustle of city life.

Monterey is known for its picturesque landscapes, where rolling fields and serene waterways create a perfect backdrop for outdoor enthusiasts. The nearby Tippecanoe River invites fishing, kayaking, and leisurely strolls along its banks, while the lush greenery surrounding the town provides ample opportunities for hiking and biking.

As a close-knit community, Monterey prides itself on its friendly atmosphere and welcoming residents. The town hosts various local events and seasonal festivities, fostering a sense of camaraderie among its inhabitants. Whether it’s the annual fall festival or summer picnics at the local park, there’s always something happening that brings neighbors together.

Education is highly valued in Monterey, with access to quality schools that prioritize student growth and community involvement. Additionally, the town’s proximity to larger cities like Plymouth and South Bend means residents can enjoy the benefits of urban amenities while relishing the peaceful charm of small-town living.

With affordable housing options and a strong sense of community, Monterey is the perfect place to call home. If you’re looking for a place that offers both natural beauty and a warm, welcoming atmosphere, Monterey, Indiana, is waiting for you to discover its delights!

Newest Listings in Monterey

$299,000

845011 MLS ⋅ 2,316 SqFt. ⋅ Gail Standefer

25+ years of automobile repair and sales were completed at this location. The opportunities are huge. 3 bedrooms, 2 bath, ranch home built in 2021 which includes a jacuzzi bathtub and living room fireplace. Attached are 2 oversized work bays with hydraulic lifts and 1 bay without. The front of the home has a very large new concrete deck with a large gazebo. Also, at the main entrance to the property there is an office building with attached garage, office and restroom that was used for detailing and car sales. In addition, the total lot size is 3+ acres which includes grass yard, fire pit and wooded area. The location has been a great source of income for the previous owner. This property is so unique you just have to come see it to believe how perfect it could be.

8790 Us-35, Monterey

Listing courtesy of Gail Standefer from Blackrock Real Estate Services.

$4,500,000

12 Baths ⋅ 202633273 MLS ⋅ Larry Nickell

Here you go a working and operating day old chicks to market meat chicken Farm on 80 acres fully modernized with computer controlled houses, feed, water and temperature control Complete Lock, Stock and Barrel sale all equipment included..8 chicken house,offices and a very nice home with pool and shops. Private Remarks: Here you go a working and operating day old chicks to market chickens fully modernized with computer controlled houses, feed, water and temperature control Complete Lock, Stock and Barrel sale all equipment included.. Directions: Take Hwy 35 south from Knox, IN to CR 800 S turn east a few miles to corner of 700E & 800 S chicken farm is on the NE corner cant miss, see signs

7800 S 700 E Rd, Monterey

Listing courtesy of Larry Nickell from Woodlands & Waters Real Estate, INC.. Cell: 219-716-3202

$4,500,000

843499 MLS ⋅ 130,482 SqFt. ⋅ Larry Nickell

7800 S 700 E, Monterey

Listing courtesy of Larry Nickell from Woodlands & Waters Real Esta.

$410,000

3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 843476 MLS ⋅ 2,492 SqFt. ⋅ Kyle Elam

Welcome to 8788 US 35 in Monterey, IN! The serene nature views of this 7.71 acre property begins with a private wooded drive and large front porch leading into the open-concept main floor living space with a back deck overlooking the picturesque back yard. The upper level of this 1,800+ sq ft home includes a large primary suite with jacuzzi tub, as well as a second full bathroom and bedroom. The lower level features a spacious bonus room with a half bath on the way to the walkout basement which includes a laundry room, bedroom, full bathroom, a large storage room and a covered concrete patio leading into the back yard. just 10 minutes from Bass Lake and 25 minutes from Lake Max in Culver! Offered As-Is, presenting a great opportunity for buyers to bring their own vision and updates.

8788 S Us Highway 35, Monterey

Listing courtesy of Kyle Elam from Blackrock Real Estate Services.

$410,000

3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 202631909 MLS ⋅ 2,492 SqFt. ⋅ Heather Friedlund

Welcome to 8788 US 35 in Monterey, IN, just 10 minutes from Bass Lake and 25 minutes from Lake Max in Culver! The serene nature views of this 7.71 acre property begins with a private wooded drive and large front porch leading into the open-concept main floor living space with a back deck overlooking the picturesque back yard. The upper level of this 1,800+ sq ft home includes a large primary suite with jacuzzi tub, as well as a second full bathroom and bedroom. The lower level features a spacious bonus room with a half bath on the way to the walkout basement which includes a laundry room, bedroom, full bathroom, a large storage room and a covered concrete patio leading into the back yard. Offered As-Is, presenting a great opportunity for buyers to bring their own vision and updates.

8788 S Us Highway 35, Monterey

Listing courtesy of Heather Friedlund from Blackrock Real Estate Services.

$47,000

202517305 MLS ⋅ Aaron Bagsby

Escape the noise and reconnect with nature on these beautifully wooded lots located just south of the serene Langenbaum Lake in Monterey, Indiana. Tucked away in the peaceful wilds of north-central Indiana, these parcels offer the perfect setting for your future cabin, retreat, or secluded getaway. Each lot provides a unique opportunity to build amidst mature trees and quiet surroundings. Easement access is in place, and multiple lots are available to suit your vision—whether you're looking for a single slice of paradise or hoping to expand your footprint across several adjoining plots. 20 lots total purchased as a whole. With flexibility in location and size, you can choose the perfect spot to match your preferences. Don’t miss your chance to secure a piece of this hidden gem—opportunities like this are rare and won’t last long.

790 N Illinois Ave, Monterey

Listing courtesy of Aaron Bagsby from Keller Williams Lafayette. Agt: 765-585-4649

$499,900

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 202524247 MLS ⋅ 2,352 SqFt. ⋅ John Schmicker

Enter into luxury with this exquisite, maintenance free and highly efficient country home on 10 acres. Conveniently located between Knox and Rochester Indiana’s 11 Lakes ! This country home blends luxury and comfort, offering an idyllic setting for relaxation and recreation. The interior features an open floor plan that maximizes natural light to showcase panoramic outside views from multiple rooms. The kitchen is a definite focal point with the huge window over-looking the out-door rec-area. The large island/bar along with the ample counter space is perfect for entertaining. The living room boasts tons of character with the high-vaulted ceiling and unique beam design w/ski-lite. All 4 bedrooms are large with vaulted ceilings and tons of natural light ! This provides ample space for family or guests to ensure everyone has their place to unwind. Lets not forget the 4 car attached garage for all the necessities ! The 17 x 24 toy-box adds to the versatility of this home, offering space for hobbies and/or extra storage. Outside, the mature oak forest offers endless opportunities for fun and relaxation. Whether you're hunting, hiking or just enjoying nature, this wooded paradise retreat is perfect for making lasting memories. This property offers a living experience compared to no other ! All new kitchen appliances included. more photos @ https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1d4PlW7RtxfcXAVkMMRbgYelt8N4nFquz

9095 E 850 S, Monterey

Listing courtesy of John Schmicker from All American Realty. Cell: 574-225-0292

$800,000

3 Baths ⋅ 202617625 MLS ⋅ Kyle Pugh

Jk Deli – Turnkey Gas Station & Popular Polish Deli in Monterey, Indiana Prime opportunity on US 35 between Winamac and Bass Lake! Jk Deli is a well-established, high-traffic gas station and authentic Polish deli located right down the road from a major camping site and one of the most popular paintball courses in Indiana. This unbeatable location serves local residents, campers, paintball enthusiasts, and daily travelers year-round. Business Highlights: • 3 gas pumps + 1 kerosene pump + diesel with steady daily volume • Fully stocked deli and convenience store with all inventory included • Complete kitchen setup and accessories ready for fresh Polish specialties • Licenses in place for alcohol, tobacco, lottery, and more • Additional income from a small home in the back – perfect for owner-occupant or rental income Located in a high-visibility spot with strong daily traffic, this is a rare turnkey business with loyal customers, multiple revenue streams, and excellent growth potential from nearby recreational traffic. Ideal for an owner-operator or investor looking for a profitable roadside business in a fantastic area.

8995 S Us Highway 35, Monterey

Listing courtesy of Kyle Pugh from Century 21 Scheetz - Carmel. cell: 463-224-2992

$239,900

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 842534 MLS ⋅ 1,483 SqFt. ⋅ Jason Wampler

ABSOLUTELY BEAUTIFUL LAKE HOME - Totally rebuilt and finished in 2019 with fabulous open concept layout. Plank flooring and recessed lighing throughout. Kitchen features granite countertops, huge island and stainless appliances. Plenty of large windows with views of Hartz Lake. Master bedroom features private bath, cathedral ceiling and second floor balcony overlooking the property and Hartz Lake. High-efficiency HVAC and on-demand water heater. Exterior features large covered deck, 1-car attached garage and storage shed. Newer very well-built 30' X 40' pole barn with concrete/electric along with 14' ceiling and plenty of lighting. 3 overhead doors and includes openers. Landscaped .65 acre lot also includes paver patio and firepit. Only steps to the water. E Orange St, Monterey.

10510 E Orange Street, Monterey

Listing courtesy of Jason Wampler from RE/MAX 1st Choice.

$119,900

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 841436 MLS ⋅ 1,104 SqFt. ⋅ Shawn Spaw

Cute ranch home on FOUR total (corner) lots for a combined 0.84 acres! You'll find so much potential here, thanks to a large living room, eat-in kitchen, full bathroom, two spacious bedrooms and a large enclosed porch/breezeway with functioning wood burning stove! Newer windows (2024), there's a detached 2-car garage and plenty of space to add a pole barn or more outbuildings so you can spread out & enjoy this beautiful property. Enjoy the serene, peaceful country life as you have plenty of privacy from your neighbors in your wooded yard and you're just down the road from Langenbaum Lake! LOW TAXES, NO HOA, super affordable utilities. Whether you're looking for an investment opportunity or a setting for your hobby farm & forever home, bring your vision and schedule your showing today!

6721 E County Road 800 N, Monterey

Listing courtesy of Shawn Spaw from Stray Dog Properties, LLC.

$299,000

3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 826950 MLS ⋅ 1,403 SqFt. ⋅ Gail Standefer

This beautiful 3-bedroom, 2-bath ranch home, built in 2021, offers modern living with a touch of luxury. It features a relaxing jacuzzi bathtub, perfect for unwinding, and a cozy living room fireplace for those chilly evenings. The home's layout is spacious and inviting, making it ideal for families, remote workers, or anyone looking for extra room. Outdoors, you'll find a large new concrete deck with a charming gazebo, perfect for entertaining or enjoying quiet moments. The expansive 3+ acre lot also includes a lush grass yard, a fire pit, and a wooded area, creating a private oasis just outside your door. Additionally, the property offers incredible business potential with an office building and garage, perfect for detailing, car sales, or any number of ventures. The large work bays with hydraulic lifts and ample space for operations make it an excellent spot for an entrepreneur or someone looking to combine work and home life in a single location.

8790 Us-35, Monterey

Listing courtesy of Gail Standefer from Blackrock Real Estate Services.

$47,000

826731 MLS ⋅ Aaron Bagsby

Escape the noise and reconnect with nature on these beautifully wooded lots located just south of the serene Langenbaum Lake in Monterey, Indiana.Tucked away in the peaceful wilds of north-central Indiana, these parcels offer the perfect setting for your future cabin, retreat, or secluded getaway. Each lot provides a unique opportunity to build amidst mature trees and quiet surroundings. Easement access is in place, and multiple lots are available to suit your vision--whether you're looking for a single slice of paradise or hoping to expand your footprint across several adjoining plots. 20 lots total purchased as a whole. With flexibility in location and size, you can choose the perfect spot to match your preferences. Don't miss your chance to secure a piece of this hidden gem

790 Illinois Avenue, Monterey

Listing courtesy of Aaron Bagsby from Keller Williams Realty - LAF.

Start Your Search

Updated . Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker of MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information. Some listings have been excluded from this website.